• Care Home
  • Care home

Orchard House Care Centre

Overall: Good read more about inspection ratings

189 Fairlee Road, Newport, Isle of Wight, PO30 2EP (01983) 520022

Provided and run by:
Barchester Healthcare Homes Limited

Important:

This care home is run by two companies: Barchester Healthcare Homes Limited and Scarborough Hall Limited. These two companies have a dual registration and are jointly responsible for the services at the home.

Assessment report published 13 November 2026

On this page

Well-led

Requires improvement

5 November 2026

Well-led – this means we looked for evidence that service leadership, management and governance assured high-quality, person-centred care; supported learning and innovation; and promoted an open, fair culture.

At our last assessment we rated this key question requires improvement. At this assessment the rating has remained requires improvement. This meant the management and leadership was inconsistent. Leaders and the culture they created did not always support the delivery of high-quality, person-centred care.

The provider remained in breach of regulation in relation to good governance. While substantial improvement had been made under new local leadership, governance and quality assurance systems were not yet consistently effective. Shortfalls were identified across care and risk records, medicines oversight, clinical monitoring and environmental risk management. Although leaders responded promptly when concerns were raised and demonstrated capacity to continue improving, the breadth of the findings showed further improvement was required to ensure governance systems consistently identified and addressed risks.

This service scored 62 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Shared direction and culture

Score: 3

The provider had a shared vision, strategy and culture. This was based on transparency, equity, equality and human rights, diversity and inclusion, engagement, and understanding challenges and the needs of people and their communities.

There had been a significant positive change in the culture of the service. The provider’s values promoted respect, integrity, empowerment and responsibility. Meeting records, audits and action plans showed an increased focus on learning and improvement. We observed stronger teamwork, communication and openness, with staff actively approaching us to discuss improvements since the previous assessment. This demonstrated the provider’s values were increasingly reflected in how staff worked together to improve people’s care.

Staff described an open, supportive and inclusive culture under the new leadership. One staff member told us, “The team culture has changed dramatically. We have a long way to go but everybody is working in the right direction,” while another said, “It’s improved massively, staff are happier, more settled.” Leaders recognised further improvement was needed and described work to promote a whole-service approach rather than separate teams working in isolation. Some people remained concerned about whether improvements would be sustained. This meant the service had established a substantially more positive and transparent culture, while recognising that continued improvement was needed to fully embed and sustain the changes for people.

Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders

Score: 3

The provider had inclusive leaders at all levels who understood the context in which they delivered care, treatment and support and embodied the culture and values of their workforce and organisation. Leaders had the skills, knowledge, experience and credibility to lead effectively. They did so with integrity, openness and honesty.

Leadership had significantly strengthened since the previous inspection. A new manager was registered, leaders were visible and approachable. They demonstrated good knowledge of people’s needs, the challenges facing the service and the improvements still required. Leadership capacity was also developing through clinical development and staff progressing into senior roles. Leaders demonstrated openness when things went wrong, including following Duty of Candour processes and sharing learning through governance arrangements. This demonstrated leaders had the knowledge, oversight and openness needed to lead the service through its continuing improvement.

Staff consistently described leaders as accessible, supportive and transparent. Staff were increasingly involved in huddles and clinical governance, and senior staff had greater involvement in oversight and decision-making. One staff member told us, “Both the deputy and the manager made such a difference. They are so much more open and transparent, very supportive.” A person using the service similarly described managers as “very good” and “approachable.” Leaders remained open about the work still required and did not suggest that all concerns had been resolved. This meant people and staff were supported by leaders who were visible, engaged and honest about both the progress made and the improvements still needed.

Freedom to speak up

Score: 3

The provider fostered a positive culture where people felt they could speak up and their voice would be heard.

The provider had strengthened arrangements for people and staff to raise concerns. Speak Up Champions were in place, supported by a whistleblowing policy and access to a Freedom to Speak Up Guardian. Staff survey feedback showed increased confidence in raising concerns, and records showed leaders investigated concerns sensitively and confidentially and shared learning where appropriate. This demonstrated the provider had established clearer routes for concerns to be raised, heard and acted upon.

Staff described feeling safer and more confident to speak openly. One staff member told us, “I feel listened to and that I have a voice,” while another said they felt “more confident about raising concerns and feel empowered to speak to management.” There remained some evidence of the previous culture, with a staff member needing reassurance that raising a concern would not result in negative consequences; however, the concern was subsequently raised. This meant staff increasingly felt able to speak up without fear and had confidence that current leaders would listen and respond to their concerns.

Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion

Score: 3

The provider valued diversity in their workforce. They worked towards an inclusive and fair culture by improving equality and equity for people who worked for them.

The provider had strengthened its approach to workforce equality and inclusion since the previous inspection. Policies reflected the Equality Act 2010 and covered discrimination, fair recruitment, development and reasonable adjustments. Equality and diversity were discussed through supervision and team meetings. Leaders gave practical examples of adapting working arrangements around individual needs and protected characteristics. This demonstrated the provider was taking action to create a more inclusive workplace and support staff according to their individual circumstances.

Staff described a significant improvement in fairness and inclusion under the current leadership. Staff asked specifically about equality, diversity and inclusion said they felt they were treated fairly and equitably and raised no concerns about their own treatment. This contrasted with the previous assessment, when staff had reported perceived favouritism, unequal treatment and difficulties obtaining reasonable adjustments. Staff survey feedback also reflected improved morale, empowerment and supportive leadership, although experiences were not universally positive. This meant staff generally experienced a fairer and more inclusive workplace, although improvements continued to embed across the workforce.

Governance, management and sustainability

Score: 1

The provider did not always have clear responsibilities, roles, systems of accountability or good governance. They did not always act on the best information about risk, performance and outcomes, or share this securely with others when appropriate.

Governance and quality assurance systems were not sufficiently effective in identifying and addressing shortfalls across the service. Audits and oversight had not identified conflicting or incomplete information within some care, risk and medicines records, including information about people’s mobility, health needs, medicines and risk-management controls. Some inaccurate information about people’s assessed needs had also not been identified through internal assurance processes. This meant leaders could not consistently rely on the information available to monitor risk, performance and outcomes for people.

Governance arrangements had not ensured known risks and required actions were consistently identified, monitored and addressed. Known environmental risks had not always been assessed or addressed promptly, medicines audits had not identified some inaccurate or conflicting information, and quality assurance had not identified gaps in required clinical monitoring and follow-up. This meant the provider’s governance systems did not provide sufficient assurance that shortfalls would be identified and addressed consistently to reduce risks to people.

There had nevertheless been substantial improvement in governance and management since the previous inspection. The provider had established audits, action plans and regular oversight, and leaders responded promptly when concerns were identified, including correcting records, escalating issues and taking action to address risks. This demonstrated the provider had strengthened its governance arrangements and had the organisational capacity to make further improvements; however, the number and breadth of shortfalls identified showed these systems were not yet sufficiently effective, embedded or sustained.

Partnerships and communities

Score: 3

The provider understood their duty to collaborate and work in partnership, so services worked seamlessly for people. They shared information and learning with partners and collaborated for improvement.

The provider worked with a range of health, social care and community partners according to people’s individual needs. Records showed appropriate referrals and positive multidisciplinary working, including with learning disability services, psychology, advocacy and local authority professionals. This demonstrated staff worked collaboratively with external partners to coordinate care and support people to access the specialist support they needed.

Feedback from external agencies was positive about partnership working and supported evidence that the service communicated and collaborated with other professionals. This meant people benefited from joined-up support, with relevant services working together to promote continuity and positive outcomes.

Learning, improvement and innovation

Score: 2

The provider did not always focus on continuous learning, innovation and improvement across the organisation and local system. They did not always encourage creative ways of delivering equality of experience, outcome and quality of life for people. They did not always actively contribute to safe, effective practice and research.

The provider had taken action to learn from previous concerns but could not demonstrate that this had consistently resulted in sustained improvement. During this assessment, we identified shortfalls in risk management, medicines, clinical monitoring and environmental safety, including areas where further improvement had previously been required. This meant the provider could not consistently demonstrate that learning had translated into effective and sustained improvement across the service.

There was, however, substantial evidence that the provider had strengthened its approach to learning and improvement. Leaders had introduced additional governance oversight, staff training, huddles, clinical governance meetings and mechanisms for sharing learning. Learning was also shared across the provider’s other services, including when things had gone wrong, while this assessment found significant improvement across the service. This represented considerable progress from the previous inspection, when oversight and quality assurance systems were ineffective. This demonstrated the provider had strengthened its capacity to learn and improve, although further time was needed to ensure changes were fully embedded and consistently sustained.