- Care home
Orchard House Care Centre
This care home is run by two companies: Barchester Healthcare Homes Limited and Scarborough Hall Limited. These two companies have a dual registration and are jointly responsible for the services at the home.
Assessment report published 13 November 2026
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Assessing needs
- Delivering evidence-based care and treatment
- How staff, teams and services work together
- Supporting people to live healthier lives
- Monitoring and improving outcomes
- Consent to care and treatment
Effective
Effective – this means we looked for evidence that people’s care, treatment and support achieved good outcomes and promoted a good quality of life, based on best available evidence.
At our last assessment we rated this key question inadequate. At this assessment the rating has changed to good. This meant people’s outcomes were good, and people’s feedback confirmed this.
Staff worked with healthcare professionals, supported people to maintain their health and independence and respected people's rights around consent.
This service scored 67 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
Assessing needs
The provider did not always make sure people’s care and treatment were effective because they did not always check and discuss people’s health, care, wellbeing and communication needs with them.
Information about people’s assessed needs was not always accurate, consistent or current. We found conflicting information about people’s mobility, repositioning, bed rails and capacity. One person receiving antibiotics for an ongoing infection did not have a current short-term infection care plan in line with the provider’s requirements. Another person’s records included health conditions they did not have. This meant staff could not always rely on people’s records for accurate and current information about their assessed needs.
There were also inconsistencies in how significant health needs were recorded. For 1 person, records contained conflicting information about mobility, skin integrity and evacuation needs. For another, the diagnosis recorded within their assessed needs and care plans differed from that subsequently confirmed with their GP. These inaccuracies had not been identified through the provider’s own quality assurance processes. This meant the provider could not consistently demonstrate that information used to assess and plan people’s care accurately reflected their current needs.
Despite these inconsistencies, care plans were generally detailed and personalised. We observed staff supporting people in accordance with their communication, care and support needs, and staff described using electronic records, handovers and huddles to understand people’s needs. One person told us, “The staff know what I need and they support me,” while another said, “The staff ask me what I need.” This demonstrated people generally experienced care that reflected their needs and preferences, although the accuracy and reliability of some assessed information was inconsistent.
Delivering evidence-based care and treatment
The provider planned and delivered people’s care and treatment with them, including what was important and mattered to them. They did this in line with legislation and current evidence-based good practice and standards.
Staff used recognised assessment tools and evidence-based guidance to plan and monitor people’s care. Records showed staff regularly assessed risks associated with malnutrition, dehydration and skin deterioration and developed detailed, personalised plans in response. For example, 1 person at high risk of malnutrition and dehydration had guidance covering fortified foods, regular monitoring, escalation to healthcare professionals and practical adaptations to support eating and drinking. This demonstrated staff used evidence-based approaches to identify changing needs and provide care that reflected people’s individual risks and preferences.
We observed staff putting personalised care into practice. Mealtimes were flexible, staff supported people to remain independent and regularly offered choices of food, snacks and drinks. Staff discussed people at risk of malnutrition and dehydration through handovers, huddles and governance meetings. People’s feedback reflected our observations, with 1 person telling us, “There’s plenty to eat and drink. They always ask me what I would like from the menu,” and another saying, “The food is very nice.” This meant people received care and support based on recognised good practice while maintaining choice, independence and involvement in their day-to-day care.
How staff, teams and services work together
The provider worked well across teams and services to support people. They made sure people only needed to tell their story once by sharing their assessment of needs when people moved between different services.
Staff worked effectively with external health and social care professionals to coordinate people’s care. Records showed involvement from GPs, district nurses, tissue viability, dietetics, dementia and learning disability services, advocacy and other professionals according to people’s individual needs. Hospital passports contained detailed information about people’s health, care, wellbeing and communication needs to support information sharing between services. This demonstrated staff shared relevant information with other services to support continuity and coordinated care.
Staff also communicated effectively across teams within the service. Daily handovers, department meetings and huddles supported information sharing, and records showed staff incorporated professional advice into people’s care. During a stand-up meeting, we observed staff sharing recent advice from a podiatrist alongside information about people’s wellbeing, clinical needs, admissions and discharges. Leaders also described advocating for people when they believed further support was required from external professionals. This meant staff and services worked together to share information, follow professional advice and support people to receive coordinated care that met their individual needs.
Supporting people to live healthier lives
The provider supported people to manage their health and wellbeing so they could maximise their independence, choice and control. Staff supported people to live healthier lives and, where possible, reduce their future needs for care and support.
Staff identified and monitored people’s individual physical and mental health needs. Care records included guidance about nutrition, hydration, skin integrity, mobility and long-term health conditions, with evidence that staff sought advice from healthcare professionals when people’s needs changed. For example, staff monitored 1 person at risk of malnutrition and dehydration, provided fortified foods and encouragement, and had arrangements to seek further healthcare input if concerns persisted. This demonstrated staff monitored people’s health and sought appropriate support to promote their wellbeing and reduce the risk of deterioration.
Staff promoted people’s independence rather than routinely completing tasks for them. We observed staff supporting people to maintain their physical and mental wellbeing through activities, nutrition, community access and access to healthcare. A relative described how their family member’s mobility had improved since admission, enabling them to walk short distances with a walking frame and staff support; they had also become more active, developed friendships and returned to knitting. This demonstrated staff supported people to maintain and regain independence while promoting physical health, wellbeing and quality of life.
Monitoring and improving outcomes
The provider did not always routinely monitor people’s care and treatment to continuously improve it. They did not always ensure that outcomes were positive and consistent, or that they met both clinical expectations and the expectations of people themselves.
Staff did not always complete required monitoring when people became unwell. Records for 1 person receiving antibiotics showed clinical observations were not consistently completed twice daily in line with the provider’s protocol, and observations requiring follow-up were not always repeated. Staff did, however, escalate concerns to healthcare professionals, which resulted in further antibiotic treatment being prescribed. This meant the provider could not consistently demonstrate that changes in people’s health and their response to treatment were monitored in line with its own requirements.
We also found gaps in follow-up monitoring after abnormal clinical observations. One person had repeated oxygen saturation readings below 90%. Records showed some observations were repeated but did not clearly explain the significance of the continued low readings or the decisions made in response. On another occasion, staff were instructed to repeat observations overnight, but the records reviewed did not show that this had been completed. This meant monitoring records did not consistently demonstrate that abnormal observations were followed up as planned.
There was positive evidence of effective monitoring and improved outcomes in other areas. Wound records included measurements, photographs, monitoring for signs of infection and planned review dates, with staff seeking support from GPs, tissue viability and occupational therapy where required. Staff described substantial improvement in a person’s wounds. This demonstrated staff used structured monitoring and professional input to support positive outcomes in other areas of care.
Consent to care and treatment
The provider told people about their rights around consent and respected these when delivering person-centred care and treatment.
The provider had significantly improved how staff assessed capacity and made best-interest decisions since the previous inspection. Mental capacity assessments were detailed, personalised and decision-specific, and records demonstrated staff involved people, relatives, legal representatives and professionals where appropriate. For 1 person, staff separately assessed capacity about medicines, bed rails and residence, recognising that capacity depended on the specific decision. When the person lacked capacity to decide where to live, records documented their wishes, advocacy and social worker involvement, consideration of alternatives and the least restrictive options. This demonstrated staff applied the principles of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 to protect people’s rights and involve them in decisions about their care.
Staff respected people’s choices and sought consent in everyday practice. We observed staff supporting people to make their own decisions, and records showed people with capacity were supported to make choices even where these might be considered unwise. People confirmed this approach, telling us, “They [staff] do ask for my consent” and “Staff ask me before they do anything.” This meant people were supported to exercise choice and control over their lives, with staff respecting their right to make their own decisions.