- Care home
Orchard House Care Centre
This care home is run by two companies: Barchester Healthcare Homes Limited and Scarborough Hall Limited. These two companies have a dual registration and are jointly responsible for the services at the home.
Assessment report published 13 November 2026
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Learning culture
- Safe systems, pathways and transitions
- Safeguarding
- Involving people to manage risks
- Safe environments
- Safe and effective staffing
- Infection prevention and control
- Medicines optimisation
Safe
Safe – this means we looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm.
At our last assessment we rated this key question inadequate. At this assessment the rating has changed to good. This meant people were safe and protected from avoidable harm.
The provider had systems to learn from incidents, safeguard people, manage infection risks and maintain sufficient numbers of suitably trained staff.
This service scored 69 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
Learning culture
The provider had a proactive and positive culture of safety, based on openness and honesty. Staff listened to concerns about safety and investigated and reported safety events. Lessons were learnt to continually identify and embed good practice.
There had been significant improvement in the learning culture since the previous inspection. Leaders used monthly clinical governance meetings to review accidents, incidents, safeguarding concerns, medicines errors and near misses, identify recurring themes and agree actions. They followed up learning through staff discussions, supervision, training, audits and action plans. This demonstrated leaders used learning from safety events to improve practice and reduce the risk of recurrence.
Staff described greater openness, transparency and involvement in learning. We observed staff discussing incidents, safeguarding concerns, medicines issues, environmental risks and lessons learned during clinical governance and stand-up meetings. Staff told us, “We have clinical governance meetings every month where we discuss all lessons learnt”, “We now have huddles which we never had before” and “All this openness and transparency has really changed the home.” Most incident records showed staff took immediate action to protect people following incidents. This demonstrated learning was shared across the service, and staff were involved in identifying concerns and improving practice.
Safe systems, pathways and transitions
The provider worked with people and healthcare partners to establish and maintain safe systems of care, in which safety was managed or monitored. They made sure there was continuity of care, including when people moved between different services.
Records showed staff coordinated people’s admissions and transitions with relevant health and care professionals. Pre-assessment information identified people’s communication and care needs, and records showed timely referrals to relevant professionals. We observed staff using daily stand-up meetings to plan admissions, respite stays and reassessments following hospital discharge. This demonstrated staff shared and reviewed relevant information to support safe and coordinated transitions between services.
Staff described structured admission processes, including pre-admission assessments, handovers and reassessments when people’s health needs changed. Leaders described preparing equipment before admission, sharing assessment information with staffcoordinating medicines for respite stays. Leaders acknowledged earlier pre-assessments had not always contained sufficient personalised detail but described improvements following leadership changes. People’s feedback supported the improvements seen, with 1 person telling us, “I moved into the home yesterday and it all went well.” This meant people generally experienced planned transitions, with systems in place to maintain continuity of their care.
Safeguarding
The provider worked with people and healthcare partners to understand what being safe meant to them and the best way to achieve that. Staff concentrated on improving people’s lives while protecting their right to live in safety, free from bullying, harassment, abuse, discrimination, avoidable harm and neglect. The provider shared concerns quickly and appropriately.
Safeguarding systems had improved since the previous inspection. All safeguarding incidents we reviewed had been appropriately raised and corresponded with statutory notifications. Records showed staff made timely referrals to the local authority where safeguarding thresholds were met and took appropriate action to protect people. Leaders maintained oversight through the safeguarding log and shared learning through daily meetings, clinical governance meetings and supervision. This demonstrated the provider had effective systems to identify, report and respond to concerns about people's safety.
People's rights were protected because the service worked within the principles of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. People can only be deprived of their liberty to receive care and treatment when this is in their best interests and legally authorised under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA). In care services, and some hospitals, this is usually through MCA application procedures called the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS). Records confirmed appropriate DoLS applications had been submitted where required and any associated conditions were being monitored and met. This helped ensure people's rights were protected whilst they received the support they needed.
Staff understood their safeguarding responsibilities and described feeling increasingly confident to raise concerns. One staff member told us, “If I thought I saw anything unethical, I would report it.” We observed staff responding quickly when people appeared vulnerable or at risk. Relatives' confidence remained mixed, including some historical concerns. However, safeguarding systems had improved, and current evidence demonstrated staff understood how to recognise, report and respond to potential harm. This meant safeguarding arrangements supported people to be protected from abuse and neglect, while confidence in the service continued to rebuild.
Involving people to manage risks
The provider worked with people to understand and manage risks by thinking holistically. Staff provided care to meet people’s needs that was safe, supportive and enabled people to do the things that mattered to them.
People’s individual risks were identified and staff understood how to support them safely. Risk assessments covered areas including nutrition, hydration, choking, skin integrity, mobility and self-neglect, and daily records generally showed staff supported people in line with agreed risk-management strategies. Staff could describe how they reduced risks associated with falls and skin integrity. This demonstrated staff understood people’s individual risks and took action to support their safety.
Staff supported people to make choices while managing risk. Risk-management plans generally reflected people’s wishes and preferences, including where choices carried increased risk. We observed staff supporting positive risk-taking without unnecessarily restricting people, including supporting a person at high risk of falls to move freely. This demonstrated staff balanced people’s safety with their independence, choices and right to do things that mattered to them.
We identified some inconsistencies and gaps within recorded risk information, including the level of detail within some risk-management controls. However, staff generally demonstrated an understanding of people’s risks and how these should be managed in practice. We considered the wider concerns about the accuracy and reliability of records as part of our assessment of governance, management and sustainability. This meant the documentary shortfalls did not reflect a wider failure by staff to understand and manage people’s risks safely.
Safe environments
The provider did not always detect and control potential risks in the care environment. They did not always make sure equipment, facilities and technology supported the delivery of safe care.
The provider had not always acted promptly to control known environmental risks. Concerns about exposed hot shower pipework had been identified prior to our assessment, but there was no specific risk assessment or documented interim controls. The absence of isolation valves also meant staff could not fully test the fail-safe function of thermostatic mixing valves. The provider isolated the affected showers when we raised this and completed an interim risk assessment. This meant the provider could not demonstrate it had consistently assessed and controlled known environmental risks to protect people from potential harm.
The provider had also been aware of concerns about a boiler and hot water system since May 2026. Although planned maintenance had taken place and monitoring was in place pending replacement, the boiler’s gas certificate had lapsed. One person told us they had avoided showering because they lacked confidence in the hot water system. The provider replaced the boiler during the assessment. This meant delays in resolving known maintenance concerns had affected 1 person’s experience and did not provide consistent assurance that the environment supported safe care.
Other environmental safety arrangements were generally effective. Fire safety records were up to date with no outstanding actions, electrical and portable appliance testing was compliant, and staff completed regular water safety checks. We observed well-maintained flooring, secure radiator covers, appropriate window restrictors and well-maintained fire safety equipment. One person also described how replacement bathroom flooring had improved their safety and independence. This demonstrated that, despite the specific shortfalls identified, the provider generally maintained the wider environment and equipment to support people’s safety.
Safe and effective staffing
The provider made sure there were enough qualified, skilled and experienced staff, who received effective support, supervision and development. They worked together well to provide safe care that met people’s individual needs.
The provider had systems to make sure enough suitable staff were deployed to meet people’s needs. The dependency tool showed sufficient staffing levels, and during the assessment we observed enough staff across the service to keep people safe and respond to their needs. Recruitment records showed appropriate pre-employment checks had been completed, including references, employment histories and Disclosure and Barring Service checks. People and relatives gave mixed feedback about staffing levels, including that staffing could vary at weekends. However, our observations and staffing records provided assurance that sufficient staff were deployed to meet people’s needs safely. This meant staffing arrangements generally supported people to receive safe and timely care, although experiences of staffing levels were not consistently positive.
Staff received training, supervision and development to support them in their roles. Training records showed staff completed statutory and additional training relevant to people’s needs, while supervision and appraisal records showed staff received regular individual support. Staff described opportunities for further development, including qualifications, leadership development and clinical training. Newly qualified nurses also received structured support when starting their roles, including buddy support and reflective supervision. This demonstrated the provider supported staff to develop the skills and knowledge required so they could work effectively and meet people’s individual needs.
Infection prevention and control
The provider assessed and managed the risk of infection. They detected and controlled the risk of it spreading and shared concerns with appropriate agencies promptly.
Infection prevention and control systems had significantly improved since the previous inspection. Audits showed leaders identified concerns, completed actions and monitored these. The current infection prevention and control risk assessment was detailed and covered the identified infection risks. Staff had completed training and cleaning schedules included routine and deep cleaning. Leaders had implemented robust control measures and recorded actions and learning within the annual infection prevention and control statement. This demonstrated the provider had strengthened systems to identify, manage and learn from infection risks.
The service was generally clean and staff followed infection prevention and control practices. We observed staff using personal protective equipment appropriately, with suitable handwashing, laundry, waste disposal and sluice facilities available. People’s experiences supported our findings, with 1 person telling us, “Oh yes, it’s always spotless! Very clean,” while a relative described the service as “Very clean, almost like a 5-star hotel.” We identified high temperatures in 2 kitchen fridges and a dirty sandwich toaster; leaders responded immediately by discarding affected food, taking 1 fridge out of use and cleaning the appliance. This meant infection risks were generally well controlled, and leaders took prompt action when concerns were identified.
Medicines optimisation
The provider did not always make sure that medicines and treatments were safe and met people’s needs, capacities and preferences.
Some medicines guidance was incomplete or inconsistent. One protocol for a medicine prescribed when required instructed staff to administer a laxative if a person had not opened their bowels for 3 days but did not explain when staff should escalate concerns if the medicine was ineffective. When we asked staff, 2 staff described different escalation arrangements. The person had reached 3 days without opening their bowels and had received the first laxative; however, no bowel obstruction or adverse outcome was identified. This meant staff did not always have clear and consistent guidance about how to monitor and escalate concerns following administration of medicines.
We also found inconsistencies within medicines records. Some topical medicines had conflicting application instructions or did not have body maps showing where they should be applied. One person's allergy information was contradictory, and another medicines protocol contained an incorrect person's name. Medicines audits had not identified the inconsistencies we found. This meant medicines records and oversight systems did not always provide reliable information to support safe medicines management.
There was positive evidence that medicines were otherwise managed safely and people were involved in decisions. Medicines administration records were generally complete with no gaps identified, storage temperatures were appropriate, and controlled medicines and transdermal patches were managed safely. Records supported safe self-administration and covert administration where applicable. Staff also worked with a person and their GP to change the timing of medicines rather than administering them covertly when the existing arrangement caused distress. One person told us, “I always get my medicines on time. I have no concerns.” This demonstrated that medicines were generally managed safely, despite the specific shortfalls identified in guidance, records and oversight