- GP practice
Merchiston Surgery
Assessment report published 26 August 2025
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Shared direction and culture
- Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
- Freedom to speak up
- Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
- Governance, management and sustainability
- Partnerships and communities
- Learning, improvement and innovation
Well-led
We looked for evidence that service leadership, management and governance assured high-quality, person-centred care; supported learning and innovation; and promoted an open, fair culture.
At our last assessment, we rated this key question as Requires improvement. At this assessment, the rating has changed to Good.
The service was in breach of legal regulation in relation to good governance. We identified the practice did not have fully effective quality assurance processes. The practice was not consistently following its own policies regarding clinical supervision and mandatory training. There was no documented evidence of regular supervision, and some staff had outstanding mandatory training. Additionally, there was no internal or external Freedom to Speak Up Guardian in place
This service scored 71 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
The service had a shared vision, strategy and culture. This was based on transparency, equity, equality and human rights, diversity and inclusion, engagement, and understanding challenges and the needs of people and their communities.
All staff had contributed to the development of the practice vision and strategy, which was kept under review. The practice was aware of the projected increase in the local population and was working with partner agencies to address future challenges.
The leadership team ensured regular communication with staff, discussing the practice’s vision, goals, and objectives. These discussions were often informal. The practice also empowered staff by providing opportunities for professional development, including supporting role transitions. For example, a receptionist was supported in their development to train as a phlebotomist, demonstrating the practice’s commitment to staff growth and career progression.
Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
The service had inclusive leaders at all levels who understood the context in which care, treatment, and support were provided. They embodied the practice’s culture and values, and led with integrity, openness, and honesty.
Leaders demonstrated the skills, knowledge, and experience necessary to lead effectively, and were highly regarded for their credibility. Staff reported that leaders were approachable and responsive to concerns, modelling the practice’s values in their day-to-day actions. Leaders were easily accessible to staff, with an open-door policy. The service had also implemented a ‘You Said, We Did’ noticeboard, which demonstrated how the practice acted on the views and feedback of staff.
Freedom to speak up
The provider’s processes did not always support people to speak up and that their voice would be heard.
At the time of our inspection, the practice did not have an internal or external Freedom to Speak Up Guardian in place. However, a staff member had recently been appointed to take on the internal guardian role. At the time of our onsite visit, the appointed individual had not yet completed the required training or fully embedded into the role. The practice also informed us that arrangements were being made to appoint an external Freedom to Speak Up Guardian through the Integrated Care Board (ICB). The practice had trained mental health first aiders in place to support staff, and leaders promoted an open-door policy to encourage open communication and a supportive working environment.
While most staff described the service as a positive working environment, several suggested improvements around internal communication and the frequency of team meetings. The experiences shared varied. Some staff reported feeling valued and supported, while others expressed that they did not always feel heard.
Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
The practice valued diversity in their workforce. They work towards an inclusive and fair culture by improving equality and equity for people who work for them. Policies and procedures to promote diversity and equality were in place. We saw senior leaders had previously addressed concerns related to discrimination. Reasonable adjustments had been made to ensure all staff were valued.
The practice provides mandatory equality, diversity, and inclusion training to all staff, ensuring they understand how to work respectfully with individuals from different backgrounds. The leadership team maintains a zero-tolerance policy for discrimination, addressing any issues, whether between staff members or in patient interactions. Health and safety risk assessments, including those for Display Screen Equipment (DSE), are regularly conducted in accordance with the Health and Safety (Display Screen Equipment) Regulations 1992. These regulations ensure that workstations are ergonomically designed to promote staff well-being, with appropriate adjustments like screen adjustors, ergonomic chairs, and standing desks. Additionally, flexible working arrangements, including varied shift patterns, are offered to staff, with signed agreements in place to support reasonable adjustments where needed.
Governance, management and sustainability
The service did not always have clear responsibilities, roles, systems of accountability or good governance. They did not always act on the best information about risk, performance and outcomes, or share this securely with others when appropriate.
The Infection Prevention and Control (IPC) lead carried out routine internal audits, including assessments of hand hygiene and aseptic non-touch technique. However, the provider was not consistently overseeing all aspects of infection prevention and control. While one of the internal audits had highlighted issues with the documentation of cleaning activities, the practice had not taken adequate steps to improve how these were recorded or monitored. As a result, cleaning schedules and reports from the external cleaning contractor were not properly completed or retained, making it difficult for the practice to demonstrate when and how frequently cleaning tasks had taken place.
In addition, the practice had not reviewed or updated its Safety Data Sheets or COSHH (Control of Substances Hazardous to Health) risk assessments to reflect a new line of cleaning products introduced by a different external cleaning company, which had taken over in April 2025.
Clinical supervision was also not being delivered in line with the practice’s policy. There was a lack of evidence showing that structured, documented supervision sessions were taking place under the guidance of a designated supervisor. The practice was unable to provide records demonstrating that ongoing clinical supervision was occurring as required by Annex A of its clinical supervision policy.
During the inspection, it was also found that some staff were not up to date with mandatory training, as set out in the practice’s training policy. The provider took steps to address this prior to the onsite visit, by which time 95% of the required training had been completed. However, four members of staff across various clinical roles still had incomplete mandatory training, in breach of policy expectations.
Partnerships and communities
The service understood their duty to collaborate and work in partnership, so services work seamlessly for people. They share information and learning with partners and collaborate for improvement.
The practice is a part of the Hawthorn and Merchiston Primary Care Network (PCN) and offers a range of extended access appointments to ensure that patients have flexibility in accessing care. This includes late evening appointments and dedicated Saturday morning slots. These extended hours aim to improve accessibility and convenience for patients.
In addition to extended access, the practice provides dedicated support for its aligned care homes by offering them a bypass number. This number enables care home staff to contact the duty doctor directly, ensuring that urgent medical concerns are addressed promptly.
Learning, improvement and innovation
The service focused on continuous learning, innovation and improvement across the organisation and local system. They encouraged creative ways of delivering equality of experience, outcome and quality of life for people. They actively contribute to safe, effective practice and research.
Leaders were able to demonstrate examples of quality improvement audits that had been carried out. For example, a recent audit focused on patients with a diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease, specifically reviewing whether certain contraindicated medications were correctly recorded. The audit aimed to ensure these medications were added to the allergy list for all relevant patients within the practice’s clinical system. To support this, the practice implemented a prompt in the clinical system that alerts clinicians to add the relevant medications to the allergy list once a patient is coded with Parkinson’s disease. At the start of the audit, only 18 out of 61 patients had these medications recorded as allergies. By the conclusion of the audit, this had improved to 100% compliance. This audit has ensured that patients with a diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease do not take medications that could cause worsening or exacerbation of their condition.
In May 2025, the pathology laboratory at Great Western Hospital in Swindon updated its Laboratory Information Management System (LIMS) software, resulting in technical issues that disrupted the transmission of test results to GP practices. Due to the scale of the disruption, a Business Continuity Incident was declared by the hospital and the Bath and Northeast Somerset, Swindon, and Wiltshire Integrated Care Board (BSW ICB). The issue became known to the practice after a patient reported missing test results. Although the missing results were promptly resent by the hospital, the practice took proactive measures to ensure patient safety by initiating its own internal audit.
The practice manually reviewed several weeks' worth of clinical appointments where blood tests may have been taken. It cross-referenced requested tests in the Integrated Clinical Environment (ICE) system with results received in their clinical system. Where results were found to be missing or incomplete, these were escalated to the hospital, or tests were repeated where clinically necessary. Clinicians were informed about the issue and reminded of the incident reporting protocols, while patients were kept updated throughout the process. As of the latest review, no patient harm had been identified. The practice continued to monitor the incident and followed up on any outstanding results to ensure patients were provided with safe and effective care.