• Doctor
  • GP practice

Merchiston Surgery

Overall: Good read more about inspection ratings

Highworth Road, Swindon, SN3 4BF (01793) 823307

Provided and run by:
Wyvern Health Partnership

Important: The provider of this service changed. See old profile
Important: The provider of this service changed. See new profile

Assessment report published 26 August 2025

On this page

Safe

Good

19 August 2025

We looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm.
At our last inspection, we rated this key question as Requires improvement. At this assessment, the rating has changed to Good.

This service scored 69 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Learning culture

Score: 3

The service had a proactive and positive culture of safety, based on openness and honesty. They actively listened to concerns about safety and thoroughly investigated and reported safety incidents. Lessons were always learnt to continually identify and embed good practice. The service and staff described a number of informal mechanisms in places to learn, educate and reflect. The provider had clear processes in place for staff to report incidents, near misses, and safety events. They had recently updated their incident reporting policy and had encouraged staff to be more open to raising concerns, to enable a positive culture on reporting without the fear of retribution and to share learning to prevent the likelihood of reoccurrence. This approach aimed to improve safety and learning outcomes across the service. We reviewed samples of the incident’s records, and we found the service had investigated and responded to patient concerns. We found documented actions recorded against each incident reviewed had been shared with relevant staff for learning

There was a system for recording and investigating complaints. When things went wrong, staff apologised and provided support to those affected. Learning from incidents and complaints led to changes that improved care for others. The service was able to demonstrate how they would apply Duty of candour.
 

Safe systems, pathways and transitions

Score: 3

The service worked with people and healthcare partners to establish and maintain safe systems of care, where safety was effectively managed and monitored. They ensured continuity of care, including when people moved between different services. There were systems in place for processing information relating to new patients, and the service collaborated with other providers to deliver shared care. Referrals and test results were managed in a timely way. A care home supported by the service described the care received as highly personalised, with consistency in the practice staff team who attend and patients being reviewed regularly.

Safeguarding

Score: 3

The service worked with people and healthcare partners to understand what being safe meant to them and the best way to achieve that. They concentrated on improving people’s lives while protecting their right to live in safety, free from bullying, harassment, abuse, discrimination, avoidable harm and neglect. The service shared concerns quickly and appropriately. Meetings were held with stakeholders regarding vulnerable patients; however, minutes of these meetings were not recorded. Individual patient records were used to document relevant information, and these records were kept up to date.
Staff were trained in safeguarding appropriately to their role. There was a designated safeguarding lead and a deputy in place, and all staff were aware of who they were and how to escalate concerns. Clinical staff members had chaperone responsibilities as part of their role, and patients were informed of the chaperone service available to them. We reviewed a sample of patient records as part of our remote clinical searches and found care plans noted how people were to be supported to remain safe. There were safe systems and processes in place to ensure children’s upcoming consultations were appropriately followed up when they failed to attend appointments. Patients who had not attend were assessed on a case-by-case basis, with opportunities offered to engage and educate them. For example, if a parent repeatedly missed immunisation appointments for their child, the nursing team would invite them in to discuss the benefits and risks, supporting informed decision-making.
 

Involving people to manage risks

Score: 3

The service worked with people to understand and manage risks by thinking holistically. They provided care to meet people’s needs that was safe, supportive and enabled people to do the things that mattered to them.
Emergency equipment was available and maintained. Staff told us they could recognise the signs of a deteriorating patient and understood what actions to take. The practice had trained staff members, including those qualified as mental health first aiders, and used a coding system to record patients' communication needs and health conditions.
Regular audits were carried out to ensure patient coding was accurate and up to date. There were also systems in place for sharing information with staff and other agencies, supporting the delivery of safe and effective care. The practice monitored delays in referrals and had processes to track urgent cases. For example, audits were conducted to ensure that urgent cancer referrals were being appropriately booked with secondary care providers. These are urgent referrals used to investigate symptoms that may indicate cancer.
 

Safe environments

Score: 3

The service detected and controlled potential risks in the environment. They made sure equipment, facilities and technology supported the delivery of safe care.
Contracts were in place to ensure the premises and equipment were properly maintained. Health and safety risk assessments and audits had been carried out, with identified risks addressed. A business continuity plan was in place and regularly reviewed.
The practice actively monitored and controlled risks in the care environment. For example, annual environmental risk assessments were conducted and reviewed more frequently when needed to ensure the safety of staff and patients. Regular checks were carried out on fire safety systems, emergency lighting, and medical equipment, supported by maintenance contracts and calibration schedules to ensure equipment remained accurate and safe to use.
Risks such as fire, hot water systems, and legionella were assessed and managed appropriately. Equipment was stored safely, routinely tested, and well maintained. The premises were clean, accessible, and equipped to support the delivery of safe care. The service had recently made adaptations to the front of the premises to improve accessibility, including levelling the floor surface and lowering a section of the reception desk to accommodate wheelchair users and reduce the risk of trips and falls.
 

Safe and effective staffing

Score: 2

The practice made sure there were enough qualified, skilled and experienced staff, who received effective support, and development. They worked together well to provide safe care that met people’s individual needs. There were a range of clinical and non-clinical roles within the practice.
During our inspection process, we found that not all staff were up to date with their mandatory training in accordance with the service’s training policy. We found 95% of mandatory training modules had been completed. However, four staff members, across various clinical roles, still had outstanding mandatory training such as Basic Life Support, as defined by the practice policy.
The service was able to demonstrate how staff were supported in developing their roles. However, it could not evidence how clinical staff and non-medical prescribers were being formally supervised, monitored, or appraised. While there were informal supervision opportunities, such as 'lunch and learn' sessions for clinical discussions and educational sessions with external guest speakers, the practice was unable to demonstrate formal, documented clinical supervision for these roles in line with the practice policy. This presented a risk that staff could prescribe outside their scope of competency without appropriate oversight. As a training practice, there were clear and externally formulated records for Foundation Year 2 doctors (FY2s) and Specialty Training Year 3 General Practitioners (ST3 GPs). An induction pack was available, and the practice also provided a clinician joining pack, which included guidance on local processes, prescribing frameworks, and referral management. However, a completed induction checklist was not observed for the most recently employed staff.
 

Infection prevention and control

Score: 2

The service did not always assess or manage the risk of infection. The practice had a newly appointed designated infection prevention and control lead, and all staff had completed relevant training. Risk assessments and audits were carried out, and recommendations were made to mitigate risks; however, these recommendations were not always completed promptly following audits.
An infection prevention and control audit completed in October 2024 identified that the existing cleaning provider had not documented what had been cleaned as part of a formalised schedule. There were no cleaning records available at the time of inspection.
Checks were being carried out for hand hygiene and aseptic non-touch technique, with evidence that staff were following appropriate protocols. Although Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) products were stored securely not all the necessary safety data sheets and associated risk assessments were in place at the time of inspection. This posed a risk to the health and safety of people using the products without guidance. Bodily fluid spillage kits were available on-site and accessible to staff, supporting safe management of potential contamination incidents. In addition, we identified the service had appropriate arrangements for the segregation and disposal of clinical waste.
 

Medicines optimisation

Score: 3

The service made sure that medicines and treatments were safe and met people’s needs, capacities and preferences. Where shortfalls were identified, they acted promptly to ensure patients received the necessary monitoring and recalls.
Medicines were stored securely and at appropriate temperatures. Staff regularly checked the stock levels and expiry dates for all medicines, including emergency medicines and vaccines. They also stored medical gases, such as oxygen, safely and completed the required safety risk assessments. Staff monitored fridge temperatures and had a clear process in place for managing any inconsistencies in the temperature range. There was a clear process for staff to follow if a temperature breach was identified, and daily temperature checks were consistently documented.
Our remote clinical searches identified most patients were receiving the recommended medicine reviews and monitoring. However, we noted that not all patients prescribed Amiodarone (used to treat ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation) had been monitored in line with national guidance. We fed back our findings to the practice, who acted immediately to address these shortfalls. Processes had been revised to include routine recall audits for patients prescribed this medicine and, following assessment, the practice demonstrated all affected patients had been recalled for routine monitoring.
The provider demonstrated actions had been taken in response to patients who had not acted upon previous monitoring recalls in line with national guidelines. The practice responded to those patients identified in the clinical searches whose blood monitoring were outside of national guideline timeframes, and recontacted patients where appropriate with compliance safety mechanisms such as reducing prescription amounts. The practice had also updated and re-shared their updated medicine monitoring standard operating procedure with staff for learning purposes.
During the clinical searches, it was also noted asthmatic patients prescribed oral steroids were not being reviewed within 48 hours, as recommended by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines. In response, the practice implemented a process within their clinical system that alerted prescribers to arrange a further review with the patient at the time of the initial acute exacerbation consultation.
All Patient Group Directions (PGDs) and Patient Specific Directions (PSDs) were completed and up to date. PGDs are written instructions that allow healthcare professionals to give certain treatments or medications to groups of patients without needing a prescription for everyone. PSDs, on the other hand, are specific instructions for an individual patient, often used when a prescription is required but needs to be tailored to that person’s specific health needs. In this case, both types of directions were reviewed and kept current, ensuring that patients receive the correct treatments as planned.