• Organisation
  • SERVICE PROVIDER

Cumbria, Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust

This is an organisation that runs the health and social care services we inspect

Important: Services have been transferred to this provider from another provider
Important: Services have been transferred to this provider from another provider

Assessment report published 8 May 2025

On this page

Safe

Requires improvement

5 March 2025

Safe – this means we looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm.

Requires improvement: This meant some aspects of the service were not always safe and there was limited assurance about safety. There was an increased risk that people could be harmed.

This service scored 50 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Learning culture

Score: 1

People, their families and carers gave us mixed feedback about the learning culture. They said they felt able to raise concerns. One person told us they felt able to talk with staff if they had concerns. However, another family member told us, “I am sick of complaining.”

Staff told us that they reported incidents which included near misses, violence and aggression, self-harm, behaviours that challenge, property damage, absence without leave and emotional abuse. Staff said that they participated in debriefs following incidents. However, two members of staff did not know what the duty of candour was, despite being given additional prompts. We found that 9 freedom to speak up reports had been submitted in the last 12 months. 8 of these were concerns raised by staff about the culture and lack of staff support on Mitford Unit. The ninth was also about Mitford Unit but was unspecified concerns.

The provider did not have a proactive and positive culture of safety based on openness and honesty. They did not listen to concerns about safety and did not investigate or report safety events. Lessons were not learnt to continually identify and embed good practice. There were processes in place to support a learning culture, however, these did not always ensure the safety of people and staff in a timely way. There were daily multi-disciplinary team (MDT) meetings where people's needs and any changes were discussed. There were handovers between each shift. There were debriefs after incidents to support lessons learned. However, some staff stated that debriefs did not always happen in a timely manner. Monthly risk registers were reviewed and were up to date. Prior to this inspection, CQC were notified by an external partner of a high level of injuries to staff working at Mitford Unit. In December 2023 the trust had reported that there were 1575 incidents of aggression and violence, of which 799 were physical assaults on staff. The report stated that “the level of violence that staff have been subjected to poses a risk of serious harm being sustained." In May 2024, this partner shared concerns that there had not been enough rapid changes to improve safety. During the inspection we found that there had been significantly high levels of use of restrictive practice at these units in the preceding 12 months. Data provided by the trust outlined that service users had experienced 491 injuries in the last 12 months on Mitford Unit, Mitford Bungalows and Rose Lodge. These are noted from 425 unique incidents, for 29 service users. There were no records of how the other injuries have been sustained, or if they were as a direct result of restraint. None of these injuries or incidents had resulted in the completion of a patient safety investigation and it was unclear how these had been reviewed including actions taken to reduce re-occurrence via learning and improved practices.

Safe systems, pathways and transitions

Score: 2

People, their families and carers gave us mixed feedback about safe systems, pathways and transitions. One family member told us “[Family Member] has been moved around too much but where she is now – Rose Lodge - she’s safe.” Another family member told us that she has no concerns regarding their family member’s safety on the ward. However, one family member of a patient at Mitford Unit said, "Sometimes I think he’s not safe, I think staying there [Mitford Unit] is making him worse.”

Staff told us that patient's needs were assessed prior to admission and that they had effective working relationships with other teams both internally and externally to the organisation. There were daily MDT meetings to discuss meeting people's needs, share risks and implement any changes to care required. However, staff at Mitford Unit said they didn't feel included in the MDT. This was fed back to the ward managers at the time of the inspection.

Feedback from partners was generally positive. One professional fed back that they had some concerns about discharging patients prematurely on Edenwood and Rose Lodge. However, in terms of Mitford, professionals expressed concerns about delays in discharge and the impact this has on people using the service, and their families.

The trust did not always work well with people and healthcare partners to establish and maintain safe systems of care. They did not always follow national best practice guidelines in relation to the use of mechanical restraint to prevent risks to vulnerable service users and did not always manage or monitor people’s safety. They did not always make sure there was continuity of care, including when people moved between different services. The service was caring for people who were delayed in their discharge. Discharge plans were in place, however, there were delays in discharging people within appropriate timescales due to a lack of suitable accommodation and providers for care packages. The trust had raised concerns with partners about the detrimental impact this had on people using the services. There were processes in place to expedite discharge, however these had failed to gather enough traction to safely move people on from the service. We also had concerns about the process used to authorise the use of mechanical restraint. The best practice policy states that all uses of mechanical restraint must be signed off by a director, even in the event of its emergency use. This is to ensure that this type of restrictive intervention has senior level oversight, but this does not always appear to take place. Data provided by the trust demonstrated incidents that included the use of emergency response belts and soft cuffs but did not provide clear recordings of the authorisation or indicated that the authorisation lacked full and proper review which exposes service users to a risk of harm.

Safeguarding

Score: 1

Family members told us they had concerns about the number of incidents that had occurred when their relatives had been accessing the community.

The ward managers were aware of reporting safeguarding matters to the local authority. Incidents were recorded electronically and this format would identify if a safeguarding referral was required. However, during the inspection we spoke to some staff who were not able to describe the internal and external processes for safeguarding individuals where concerns had been raised. Some staff raised concerns to us that some of their colleagues did not appear to be experienced and knowledgeable about patients and safe practices and described an incident where one staff member had run away during an incident leaving other staff and the patient at further risk.

We observed staff supporting people to remain safe both within the unit and accessing the community. There were sufficient staff on duty to meet people's needs. However, at Mitford Unit, we did observe staff being overly present, even when people were not in a state of distress. We observed that this appeared to be overwhelming and intimidating for the patients involved. We spoke with the ward managers about how staffing was organised when people were in a state of calm or relaxed mood, so there wasn't always the presence of so many staff. Staffing was not organised to facilitate this and we were told there was no lead staff member who would direct the staff as to who needed to do what to support the person correctly. During the onsite visit we had concerns about the responsiveness of the management team to a safeguarding allegation a patient had made to a member of CQC staff in the course of our discussions with them. We raised this with the senior leadership team and they later provided us with assurances that appropriate action had been taken.

The safeguarding processes in place at the service did not always ensure the safety of people using it. Data reported to CQC by the trust showed there were 491 injuries to service users in the previous 12 months on Mitford Unit, Mitford Bungalows (now closed) and Rose Lodge. These were noted from 425 unique incidents for 29 service users. This included 13 recorded as moderate harm, 338 recorded as low / minor harm, and 74 recorded as no harm. One service user had 105 injuries noted, one had 47, one had 42 and one had 33. Of the incidents reported, 241 were noted as being ‘self-harm’. There was no record of how the other injuries had been sustained, or if they were a direct result of restraint. In the previous 12 months, there had been 31 safeguarding referrals for Rose Lodge, 18 for Mitford Unit and 3 for Edenwood. The number of safeguarding referrals did not reflect the high number of incidents recorded. Leaders had not ensured that people were safeguarded as a result of being harmed. We were concerned that not all staff had received appropriate safeguarding training. For example, at Edenwood only 37% of staff had undertaken level 3 safeguarding training, this figure was 12% at Mitford Unit and 26% at Rose Lodge. The provider’s Safeguarding Adults at Risk and Safeguarding Children policies were viewed and were in date.
 

Involving people to manage risks

Score: 3

People and their families spoke positively about the management of risk. One family member told us, “We have every confidence in Mitford [regarding restraints]" and “Now there are less people [care staff] around him, the lead nurse says he’s less challenging. He’s now able to tell people how he feels." They also told us, “Things have improved, there are less incidents now, less seclusions, the last one was only for a few hours.” At Rose Lodge, one family member told us she understood her family member had to be restrained as “he can escalate his behaviours” however, she felt her family member was "quite happy" and "settled" on the ward. However, another family member at Rose Lodge told us their son had been restrained on the ward and it can take up to 4 or 5 staff to restrain him. He now “comes out more and more [during the day] but at night they [staff] lock the door and that’s not correct."

Staff told us that the whole of the MDT are involved in seclusion of patients and that any restraints lasting for 10 mins or more are reported following which debriefs should be held to determine additional support for the patient. MDT and HOPES teams were also involved for patients who had high levels of restraint identified. However, some staff told us that there can be multiple incidents a day and decisions aren't made on time and there were always plans in place to mitigate further risks.

We identified significant concerns relating to the use of restrictive interventions. These concerns related to the use of prone and mechanical restraint, staff competency, governance and oversight. The trust’s Practice Guidance Note for the use of mechanical restraint noted that the trust had taken a decision to deviate from National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidance, approving the use of mechanical restraint outside of a secure setting. However, there was no rationale for this deviation. Data provided by the trust showed that mechanical restraint had been used on 52 occasions on Mitford Unit in 12 months and that prone restraint had been used 518 times with 12 patients over a 12-month period, across all 3 units. Recordings of these episodes did not always identify that restrictive interventions were used in line with the Mental Health Act (MHA) Code of Practice Code of Practice. We also had concerns about the use of prone restraint with individuals for who the use of this would be considered high risk and, with people whose care plans outlined that prone restraint should not be used due to a significant risk of positional asphyxiation and placed the person at risk of harm or death. People had Positive Behaviour Support (PBS)plans in place to guide staff on how best to support them, however, some lacked specific information to guide staff on how to best support individuals. They did not always include details on how to support the service user to avoid becoming distressed, what methods could be used to support the service user at times of distress that do not involve restrictive practices. Care and behavioural support plans did not always include what restrictive practice(s) have been individually agreed for each service user, how to safely use them, and any associated risks to the individual from different forms of restraint. Following our assessment, the trust made an undertaking to reduce the use of prone and mechanical restraint with a view to elimination within 12 months. The trust established an internal HOPE(S) lead role and awareness training was provided to staff.

Safe environments

Score: 2

Family members told us they were unable to comment on the facilities, particularly patients' rooms, as they were unable to see them. A family member at Edenwood said, "I don’t know what his environment is like, but I would like to see his room. They [provider] need to revisit their policy on visiting." Another told us, “I’ve never seen his room or been inside the unit, but it’s quite echoey, (where they meet) and there’s a lot of door banging.”

There was a maintenance team available. Risks to people's environments had been assessed. There were regular MDT meetings to discuss people's needs and how to keep them safe. Staff told us that they had significant concerns about their own safety whilst working on the ward and several staff had sustained significant injuries.

At Mitford Unit, the environment was clean and tidy. People's rooms were personalised. People had ensuite showering/toilet facilities. There were also communal baths available. Environmental risk assessments, including ligature risks, had been undertaken. People had access to their own outside space. However, we observed sparse areas and a lack of communal space for people outside of their own bedrooms. The environment at Rose Lodge was worn in places. The bath in the assisted bathroom was not working and we were told by staff that it had not been for some time and a hoist was in a room crammed with old mattresses. The courtyard was tidy but sparse. Staff said this was because it was being refurbished. Signs on doors did not align with what the rooms were being used for. For example, a bedroom was being used for storage and an activity room was being used as an office. However, the ward was clean and tidy, furniture was solid but not overly clinical in appearance and there were pretty murals and information posted on the walls. Patients did not have unsupervised access to rooms with ligature points. Blind spots were mitigated by using one-to-one observations for all patients on the ward.

The provider did not always detect and control potential risks in the care environment. They did not always make sure equipment, facilities and technology supported the delivery of safe care. Clinical environment risk assessments were completed for all the units and were in date, with relevant action plans. Equipment checks were regularly carried out. Fire and health and safety policies were up to date. During our visit to Mitford Unit we found that the environment was highly restrictive due to the nature of the people using the service. People were mainly restricted to their own area of the building and there were no shared communal spaces.

Safe and effective staffing

Score: 1

People and their family members gave us mixed feedback regarding staffing. Several family members told us there had been issues with staff historically but this has been resolved now and there were lots of new staff. Another family member told us their relative is funded 2-1 24 hours a day however their relative “wants to go out into the corridor, but there’s periods where he couldn’t because there was only 1 staff on.” Some family members told us there was a lot of agency staff used. Family members also told us there were enough staff but there were issues with the consistency of staff. One family member told us her relative didn't like any of them. Another family member said, “He has to have people [staff] he likes otherwise he won’t go out, in the end they [provider] put a core team together, things are going well now.” Another family member said, “We have a good relationship with all the staff, I can’t fault them” and "Always enough staff, yes.” He now has a better relationship and one of the staff rings him every week. Another family member said, "The staff are proactive.”

Staff raised concerns about new members of staff not having the necessary skills and experience to support people. This on occasion had led to staff "running away" from situations and not supporting people appropriately. This had put both staff and patients at risk. We discussed this with the ward manager who explained the induction process and support for new staff. The ward managers said they were aware of this and it had been discussed at team meetings. We were told by the ward managers that supervisions had improved as compliance was poor. Ward managers said they had new staff at onboarding stage and others on annual leave, hence the reason for low supervision compliance. There was a supervision tree in place. Bi-monthly supervisions should take place. A supervision was an hour with their manager, which they may not all get but they did get informal time/debriefs. However, staff on Mitford Unit told us that debriefs did not always happen or happen in a timely manner which impacted on learning from incidents and increased risks to service users.

We observed patients were supported in a timely manner and did not have to wait for support. However, we did observe a large number of staff in people's corridors at all times. Most of the time they would be observed to be sitting outside people's bedrooms unless engaged in an activity. During the assessment site visit on 18th July, a patient moved towards the inspector in a non-threatening manner. 4 staff then stood up and moved towards the patient. There was no clear reason as to why 4 staff needed to respond, nor did staff consider the impact their actions may have had on the patient, or how it would make them feel. There were no considerations as what impact high levels of staffing were having on patients, nor was there any consideration as to what impact staffing levels were having on patients’ distress and risk of harm. One incident record of prone restraint showed 11 staff members being involved to support a patient when they were distressed. There was no consideration about how the presence of 11 staff may increase patient distress. There was no record of an identified lead staff member to ensure during restraint that patient’s head and neck were safe, airways and breathing were not compromised, vital signs were monitored, the restraint was necessary, proportionate and only used for the shortest time possible and everyone involved was safely supported throughout the process.

During the assessment, staff told us that some colleagues were not experienced, unskilled and often ‘ran away’ from incidents leaving other staff and service users at risk of harm. This is corroborated with evidence of 799 assaults taking place on staff in the last 12 months as reported by the Health and Safety Executive. Whilst some of these assaults had occurred in Mitford Bungalows, which was not included in the scope of this inspection, the staff teams and service users from the bungalows had transferred to Mitford Unit and we were not assured that the change of environment, or the measures in place were sufficient to reduce, or mitigate risks to service users and staff. The trust failed to deploy sufficiently skilled and competent staff to support service users at times of distress. We also had concerns about the levels of training provided to staff who engaged in episodes of mechanical restraint. The trust’s mechanical restraint policy states that mechanical restraint equipment should only be used by trained staff. The trust failed to provide any evidence of this training in the mandatory staff training records supplied to us during the inspection period. Staff turnover and sickness was higher on Mitford Unit than at Rose Lodge and Edenwood. Clinical supervision, managerial supervision and annual appraisal completion levels were significantly lower at Mitford Unit than the other two units. Only 37% of staff on Mitford Unit had received a clinical supervision, 32% had received a managerial supervision and 40% had received an annual appraisal. Many staff training courses were below the 85% trust completion rate. The trust informed us that clinical staff within autism services were undertaking specific training to enable them to be more responsive to individual patient needs. This included; Positive Behaviour Support training through the British Institute of Learning Disabilities (BILD), Reducing Restrictive Intervention MSc and Makaton training to enhance communication with specific patients.

Infection prevention and control

Score: 3

No concerns regarding infection control or cleanliness were raised by family members or carers. However, visiting family members took place outside of the clinical environment in a dedicated visiting room so they were not able to observe clinical areas directly.

There was a maintenance team available. Risks to people's environments had been assessed. There were regular MDT meetings to discuss people's needs and how to keep them safe.

At Mitford Unit, the environment was clean and tidy. People's rooms were personalised. People had ensuite showering/toilet facilities. There were also communal baths available. Environmental risk assessments, including ligature risks, had been undertaken. People had access to their own outside space. The environment at Rose Lodge was worn in places. The bath in the assisted bathroom was not working and we were told by staff that it had not been for some time. The courtyard was tidy but sparse. Staff said this was because it was being refurbished. Signs on doors did not align with what the rooms were being used for. For example, a bedroom was being used for storage and an activity room was being used as an office. However, the ward was clean and tidy, furniture was solid but not overly clinical in appearance and there were pretty murals and information posted on the walls. Patients did not have unsupervised access to rooms with ligature points. Blind spots were mitigated by using one-to-one observations for all patients on the ward.

Clinical environment risk assessments were completed for all the units and were in date, with relevant action plans.

Medicines optimisation

Score: 3

People and their families spoke positively about medicines. One family member told us she had no concerns regarding medications and is fully informed of their family members medication regime and doses. Another family member told us their son had an emergency epilepsy protocol which was included in their care plan and the lead clinician was "great" and "very proactive".

People were supported to receive their medicines in a way which met their needs. Staff we spoke with at Mitford knew of the patient’s individual needs however this was not always reflected in care plans we looked at. Staff informed us they could access advice on medicines through various channels and felt supported in medicines management on the wards. The hospital site where Mitford was located ward had access to facilities to monitor patient’s physical health needs as well as dedicated staff on the unit. At Rose Lodge we were told how the pharmacist was integrated into the local GP service for patients located on their ward which enabled high level oversight of any physical health needs. Pharmacy audits relating to medicines were taking place regularly and included prescribing and omitted doses each month, as well as ‘hot topics’ which for example included reviews of benzodiazepines

Medicines on all the wards were stored safely and securely. Temperature monitoring was in place. We saw evidence of ongoing medicines reviews as part of multi-disciplinary team meetings and patients had the opportunity to input to these where they could. We also saw evidence of interventions from the clinical pharmacy team regarding advice and interventions around medicines. We saw evidence that STOMP and STAMP principles had been applied to patients’ medication regimes.

The records we looked at we could see evidence of medicines reconciliation whether that be transfer from an internal location or from an external provider. All electronic prescribing records we looked at contained no medicines to be used in rapid tranquilisation. For other medicines prescribed orally to be used on a when required basis to manage anxiety and agitation, incident forms were completed on every occasion to identify any themes and trends. Mental Health Act consent to treatment documents were accessible to staff at the point of administration on their online system. Review of these documents showed that for people we looked at prescribing of medicines was in line with T2, T3 or section 62 paperwork. Staff ensured each persons’ physical health was monitored regularly; however, this information was sometimes hard to locate and there were inconsistencies in where this was recorded. They had recently started to make use of the National Early Warning Scores (NEWS2) to improve detection of and response to clinical deterioration. This would also ensure physical health monitoring information was located in a central place.