- SERVICE PROVIDER
Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust
This is an organisation that runs the health and social care services we inspect
Assessment report published 17 March 2026
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Shared direction and culture
- Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
- Freedom to speak up
- Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
- Governance, management and sustainability
- Partnerships and communities
- Learning, improvement and innovation
Well-led
At our last inspection we rated this key question good. At this inspection the rating has changed to requires improvement. We identified 1 breach of the regulations in relation to governance. The score of 1 for the ‘Governance, management and sustainability’ quality statement limits the overall key question score rating to requires improvement.
Requires improvement: Governance processes were not always effective at providing managers and senior leaders with consistent oversight of teams’ performance. There were differences in the quality of people’s care records across teams. However, leaders had the skills, knowledge and experience to perform their roles. Staff knew and understood the trust’s vision and values and how they applied their work. Staff felt respected, supported and valued. The service worked well with partners to support people who used services. Staff had opportunities to be involved in research and quality improvement projects.
This service scored 62 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
Most of the service had a shared vision, strategy and culture. However, some staff found the recent changes to the service confusing.
At the time of our inspection, the trust was in the process of making significant changes to its adult community mental health service through its community transformation. Some changes had already been implemented, such as the division of local authority and community mental health teams (CMHTs). Some staff told us they had attended listening events and sessions to prepare staff for the split from the local authority.
Managers and senior leaders could clearly articulate the transformation’s aims and objectives. However, some staff told us they were confused about some of the changes and the reasons for these, such as the move from allocating care co-ordinators to allocating key workers and the splitting of some teams in care hubs.
Most staff understood the community transformation’s main aims to provide more preventative care and treatment in people’s local areas. They also told us they were aware that not all teams currently worked in the same way and that standardisation was needed to reduce health inequalities for people who used services.
Teams and staff displayed the trust’s values of kindness, fairness, ingenuity and determination. Even in teams that were struggling with resource challenges, such as Bury CMHT, staff told us they continued to work through the challenges to ensure people had the best care possible.
Teams across the adult community mental health service all displayed positive workplace cultures based on teamwork and trust. Most staff told us how supported they felt by colleagues and that they knew they could always speak to colleagues to get advice or support.
Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
The service had inclusive leaders at all levels who understood the context in which they delivered care, treatment and support and embodied the culture and values of their workforce and organisation. Leaders had the skills, knowledge, experience, and credibility to lead effectively. They did so with integrity, openness, and honesty.
Leaders had the skills, knowledge, and expertise to perform their roles. Leaders spoke to us with openness and expressed passion and pride when telling us about the work their teams were doing, whilst acknowledging areas they wanted to improve.
Leaders understood the services they oversaw. They told us about specific challenges their teams experienced including any recent incidents. Leaders spoke enthusiastically and knowledgably about quality improvement work that was underway and how their teams supported the delivery of care to different populations.
Managers and leaders were accessible to staff. Staff across all teams told us they felt supported by managers and that they found managers and leaders approachable. They all told us they felt able to seek support from managers and leaders as needed. Across teams, staff praised managers and leaders for their skills, knowledge, support, and leadership.
Staff had access to the trust's senior leadership and staff told us about times they had contacted the trust's CEO and had responses from him in relation to queries or concerns they had.
Some staff across teams told us leaders were not always visible to all teams. However, some leaders told us they made additional efforts to regularly base themselves in different teams to ensure they stayed connected. Some staff in one team told us they had requested more visible leadership presence, which their manager had escalated and had led to leaders committing to more regular visits to the team.
Some staff told us that trust senior leadership were quite involved in their work. For example, some staff in early intervention teams (EIT) said the trust CEO sometimes attended the EIT away days. Staff also told us about the regular trust senior leadership newsletters and question time events. Some staff told us they felt they could directly contact the trust senior leadership and had previously emailed the trust's CEO about their concerns.
Most staff spoke positively about training and development opportunities such as leadership development. Some of the managers and senior leaders we met told us they had been supported to develop their professional roles within the trust. For example, some staff had been supported to become Consultant Social Workers, and multi-professional Approved Clinicians and Responsible Clinicians.
Staff, managers and senior leaders spoke positively about the value and importance of having staff with lived experience of using services being part of their team.
Freedom to speak up
The service fostered a positive culture where people felt they could speak up and their voice would be heard.
The trust had a Freedom to Speak Up Guardian and Freedom to Speak Up Ambassadors across teams. Most staff and managers were aware of Freedom to Speak Up and told us they felt able to raise any concerns within their team. Managers across teams told us they tried to foster an open and supportive environment in which they hoped staff would feel able to raise any concerns directly with them.
The trust marked National Freedom to Speak Up month in October each year. In 2024, it used Freedom to Speak Up month to promote work around the role and recruitment of Freedom to Speak up Ambassadors.
In May 2025, a Freedom to Speak Up deep dive review of concerns raised in 2024/25 was presented at the People and Workforce Committee. It showed that across the trust there was almost double the number of concerns raised compared with the previous year. The data was not specific to the adult community mental health service. Across the trust, the most frequently reported concerns related to policy and procedures, bullying and harassment, management practices, and worker safety and wellbeing. The paper made several recommendations and noted that some of the actions were being included in the ongoing work to create the trust’s Freedom to Speak Up Strategy.
The trust had reviewed its Freedom to Speak Up provision against the 5 recommendations for all trust boards made by the National Guardians Office. The trust had a full time Freedom to Speak Up Guardian role, and the draft Freedom to Speak Up Strategy addressed the other recommendations in relation to strengthening feedback loops, investing in line manager training and monitoring resolution and impact.
Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
The service valued diversity in their workforce. They worked towards an inclusive and fair culture by improving equality and equity for people who worked for them.
The trust had a range of staff support networks that supported staff equality and diversity. The staff support networks provided opportunities for staff to seek support and learn from each other. The trust told us the networks also aimed to influence positive change across the trust, support the career development of their members, and help the trust improve its understanding of the needs of both staff and people who used services.
Staff could attend support networks including:
- Carers Network,
- Faith and Beliefs Network,
- LGBTQ+ Network and Allies Group,
- Men’s Wellbeing Network,
- Neurodiverse Network,
- Positive Ability Network,
- Race Equality Network,
- Women’s Network.
Some of the networks, such as the Men’s Wellbeing Network, organised events and talks to promote wellbeing for its members.
The trust had health and wellbeing champions across services. Champions were from all staff levels, demographics and backgrounds. They signposted colleagues to local and national health and wellbeing support offers and met regularly to connect and share ideas.
The trust undertook equality monitoring to ensure its staffing was diverse and representative of the people who used services. The trust reviewed its 2024/2025 Workforce Race Equality Standard (WRES) and Workforce Disability Equality Standard (WDES) results and identified actions to improve equity for racialised and disabled staff. The actions were taken forward and reported through the Equality, Diversity and Inclusion working group. WRES and WDES data are only available at trust-wide level.
The trust carried out equality impact monitoring through staff surveys. These helped senior leaders assess the impact of equality and diversity initiatives on staff’s experiences at work. For example, the trust had introduced a Lead Positive Programme which developed professional and interpersonal skills to address systemic discrimination.
The trust had a zero-tolerance approach to discrimination. The trust website included their anti-racism statement and transgender and non-binary statement.
Most staff and managers told us that the trust was supportive of offering flexible working arrangements to staff. The Flexible Working Policy and Procedure supported staff who wished to make flexible working requests and stated the stages and timeframes of the process. Some staff told us about their own flexible working arrangements that supported their caring responsibilities or health needs. There were also staff who had flexible retirement arrangements to allow them to continue working after retirement.
Governance, management and sustainability
There were inconsistencies in responsibilities, roles, systems of accountability and governance across care hubs and teams, which the trust was in the process of standardising. The quality of care records varied across teams. However, the service mostly acted on the best information about risk, performance and outcomes.
Across teams and care hubs, there were inconsistencies in how teams operated. Processes were not always effective at ensuring people who used services received care and treatment that was delivered by sufficiently trained and supported staff or their experience of care was of a consistent standard across teams.
Staff and managers were able to articulate how information flowed up and down through governance structures between staff and senior leaders. We saw care hubs held monthly meetings that covered key issues such as quality, workforce, performance and finance. However, there was not a consistent governance structure across network meetings. We saw that north and south networks’ governance meeting minutes varied considerably. In Stockport and Tameside and Glossop, monthly ‘care hub, quality, operations, performance and finance’ meetings were held. Minutes of these meetings showed a lack of consistency in agenda items. Heywood, Middleton and Rochdale, Oldham, and Bury had monthly integrated quality and operations meetings. Again, minutes of these meetings showed a lack of consistency in agenda items. This meant it was unclear how some information flowed up and down in a way that ensured consistent oversight across the service.
The trust had several processes in place to monitor and review how it supported people who were under Community Treatment Orders (CTO) to ensure they were made aware of their rights. However, data showed that people did not always have their rights under CTOs explained to them in line with trust policy.
Care records in most teams included holistic, person-centred and up to date risk assessments, care plans and safety plans. However, in Bury CMHT and Heywood and Middleton CMHT, we identified out of date care plans and risk assessments that were also not person-centred. Heywood and Middleton CMHT had already planned to address gaps in care records soon after our inspection.
Staff did not consistently record people’s consent to care and treatment in their care records. We reviewed 31 care records in relation to consent. Of those 31 records, consent was not clearly recorded in 6 people’s records. This meant the service could not be assured that people had understood their care and treatment and provided informed consent.
At the time of our inspection, the trust was undertaking a trust-wide review of its governance systems and structures. Work was in progress to develop a new community pathway standard operating procedure to align with the community transformation. Senior leaders told us they recognised there was variation in service delivery and team composition across teams, which they were in the process of addressing to provide greater consistency and equity for both staff and people who used services.
The trust had identified from other CQC inspections during 2025 that its staff had not all been correctly allocated the mandatory training courses necessary for their roles. It had addressed the training gaps and was making improvements in the compliance rates of essential and mandatory training courses at the time of our inspection. However, this did mean that some staff were not up to date in essential subjects such as the Mental Health Act 1983, and we saw that people under Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) were not always given their rights in line with trust policy and Mental Health Act 1983 expectations. When we last inspected the adult community mental health service, we told the trust it was in breach of legal regulations in relation to staff training compliance.
However, some of the trust’s governance processes were effective. The adult community mental health service had plans for emergencies that were specific to each team. Teams’ business continuity plans included instructions for managers and staff to follow in a range of emergency situations to limit the impact on service delivery. The business continuity plans included clear escalation processes.
Information governance systems protected the confidentiality of people’s information, such as care records.
Managers had access to the necessary information to support them with their management roles. This included information on the performance of the service, staffing and people who used services. Managers across CMHTs and EIT told us the format of duty and caseload data had recently been changed to a new spreadsheet. They told us this enabled all staff to easily access it, which helped to ensure team oversight of people’s risks, care needs and treatment, as well as staff workload.
Staff maintained and had access to risk registers for each care hub. The risks documented on the risk registers reflected issues staff and managers told us about. For example, Oldham care hub’s risk register included a risk related to staffing levels in CMHTs, and Bury’s risk register included a risk about demand for CMHT services being greater than commissioned capacity. The trust’s medicines management risk register included a risk about lack of shared care agreements for some people who used services, which reflected what staff and managers had told us. Each risk was assigned an impact score, actions and action owners. A target date was set for each impact score to be lowered.
Staff in the adult community mental health service undertook or participated in local clinical audits. Managers told us this helped provide assurance and identify where improvements were needed. Audits included topics such as the safe and secure handling of medicines and infection prevention and control in community clinics.
Partnerships and communities
The service understood their duty to collaborate and work in partnership, so services worked seamlessly for people. They shared information and learning with partners and collaborated for improvement.
Staff at all levels told us about the importance of working collaboratively with partners and other agencies to provide holistic, effective and safe care to people who used services. They told us this helped to support people’s biopsychosocial needs. For example, some staff told us about local voluntary, community and social enterprise groups they worked with to support people with substance misuse or housing needs.
The adult community mental health service’s Living Well neighbourhood mental health teams were delivered in partnership with primary care networks. They provided support to people whose needs were more complex than GPs could support but not complex enough to require community mental health team (CMHT) support. Staff and managers told us how the service had co-designed, co-developed and co-delivered the Living Well neighbourhood mental health teams with partners including housing and homelessness teams, employment services, substance misuse services, domestic abuse services, family hubs and education services. They told us this helped to provide a pathway for people who used services that supported them holistically and helped to reduce health inequalities.
The trust’s clinical strategy 2023-2028 outlined the trust’s commitment to strengthening relationships and working in partnership with local organisations to support people’s mental health and wellbeing. It stated its aim was to provide seamless pathways for people who used services between primary and secondary care by working in partnership with primary care and the local authority.
The adult community mental health service shared information and learning with other organisations. For example, senior leaders met regularly with Directors of Public Health in their localities and were members of each borough’s ‘Locality Board’, participating in initiatives such as Neighbourhood Health Pilots in Rochdale and Stockport.
When serious incidents occurred, the trust informed the relevant bodies and worked with the relevant organisations such as the police, to investigate and share learning. Senior leaders told us they informed their commissioners about serious incidents or concerns and attended regular Provider Oversight Meetings. The trust’s board papers evidenced close working with the ICB on a range of issues that affect service delivery, such as business plans and finances.
The trust had carried out stakeholder mapping as part of implementing the Patient Safety Incident Response Framework (PSIRF). It had subsequently invited those external agencies and third-party organisations identified into internal governance processes to ensure robust oversight and understanding of any incidents. For example, the physical health strategic group included representation from acute trusts to help strengthen physical health support for people with severe mental illness. The trust’s suicide prevention and self-harm reduction steering group had representation from neighbouring mental health trusts and voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations.
Staff were involved in planning and overseeing people’s care with other agencies. For example, some staff told us they regularly attended section 117 discharge planning meetings for people who were due to be discharged from inpatient services. Section 117 aftercare is for people who are discharged after having been detained in hospital under certain sections of the Mental Health Act, to provide them with help and support once they are discharged. The trust told us staff also attended Multi Agency Public Protection Arrangements (MAPPA) meetings, Multi Agency Risk Assessment Conference (MARAC) and Multi Agency Vulnerable Offenders Panel (MVOP) meetings as needed.
Learning, improvement and innovation
The service focused on continuous learning, innovation and improvement across the organisation and local system. They encouraged creative ways of delivering equality of experience, outcome, and quality of life for people. They actively contributed to safe, effective practice and research.
Most staff across different teams told us about quality improvement work that was underway. For example, some staff told us about the service’s efforts to increase feedback by adding the Friends and Family Test QR code to all correspondence with people who used services.
Improvement projects were delivered either through the change champions programme, or external improvement collaboratives, with support from the trust’s Improvement Team. Executive sponsors attended celebratory learning events in which improvement projects were presented. One of the recently celebrated quality improvement projects was the creation of an autism and learning disability guidebook for community mental health team (CMHT) staff to increase their awareness in this area.
Quality improvement projects were monitored to assess their effectiveness and make recommendations. For example, a pilot that implemented a pharmacist prescriber within Living Well neighbourhood mental health teams evidenced that pharmacist prescribers helped to maximise the benefits of multidisciplinary care and reduced medication-related harm. Recommendations from the pilot included commissioning the roll out of the pharmacist prescriber role across Living Well neighbourhood mental health teams.
Opportunities to be involved in learning, research and innovation were available to people who used services and carers. In some teams, staff told us there were staff leads identified for research and getting people who used services involved.
At the time of our inspection, staff and people who used services were involved in a range of clinical research trials. For example, staff and managers told us about ongoing research into preventing suicide in people with psychosis through the use of cognitive behavioural therapy and working with the Black African community to deliver care in a way that is more culturally aware and not harmful to them.
The service used innovative approaches to share learning. For example, it hosted a series of human library events in which people who used services told their stories and shared their experiences of receiving care and treatment. The trust told us that staff feedback had been positive about the initial event, and so it had delivered and planned for more human library events. We saw evidence that many quality improvement and innovation projects were co-produced with people who used services and carers.