- Residential substance misuse service
Shardale St Annes
Assessment report published 3 October 2025
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Shared direction and culture
- Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
- Freedom to speak up
- Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
- Governance, management and sustainability
- Partnerships and communities
- Learning, improvement and innovation
Well-led
This means we looked for evidence that service leadership, management and governance assured high-quality, person-centred care; supported learning and innovation; and promoted an open, fair culture.
At our last assessment we rated this key question good. At this assessment the rating has changed to requires improvement.
This meant the service management and leadership was inconsistent. Leaders and the culture they created did not always support the delivery of high-quality, person-centred care.
The service did not have clear and strong governance processes to ensure that the service was running effectively and to provide managers with appropriate oversight, monitoring and assurance.
Following the on-site assessment, we requested further information from the service to support our review and judgements of the governance of the service. The service did not provide any of the information that we had requested due to unforeseen circumstances that impacted on the Registered Manager’s ability to fulfil the information requests. The Registered Manager had stated that they were the only person who would be able to respond to requests made by the CQC, although it was not clear why this was the case with having a staff team including a trainee manager on-site. Therefore, we were concerned that in the physical absence of the Registered Manager there was no clear governance oversight relating to the running of the service.
However, staff and managers were passionate about the service and the positive impact it had on the clients.
The service was in breach of regulation for governance at the service.
This service scored 54 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
The service had a philosophy which underpinned the therapeutic model used. The service aimed to create and build a therapeutic community to support the individual clients on their journey of recovery.
Staff spoke passionately about the service and the therapeutic model, including the positive impact it could have for the clients who engaged in it.
Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
The Registered Manager, who was also the Nominated Individual and owner of the service, had been managing the service mostly off-site for the 6 months prior to the assessment due to circumstances not related to work. They told us that they had still maintained regular contact with the service and were providing support remotely.
The Registered Manager was experienced and passionate about the service they were providing.
However, we had significant concerns about how the service was being managed and that the Registered Manager was solely responsible for the majority of the oversight and governance processes in the service. This meant that when the Registered Manager was not on-site, there was a lack of clear or robust processes to ensure that the service was being managed safely and effectively.
Freedom to speak up
The service had a whistleblowing policy which was accessible to staff, although the service was a stand-alone service with a small staff team.
Managers described how they believed they promoted an open and honest culture within the service.
Staff that we spoke to did not raise any concerns that they would not be able to escalate any concerns that they had and felt comfortable that they would be able to do so without fear of reprisal.
The service held regular community meetings that clients attended and promoted the client voice within the service. Clients that we spoke to did not raise any concerns that they would not be able to speak to staff or managers if they had an issue or concern within the service.
Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
The service had an equality and diversity policy. Managers described how they would support staff in undertaking their roles. Staff that we spoke to did not raise any concerns about workforce equality, diversity and inclusion.
Governance, management and sustainability
The service did not have clear and strong governance processes to ensure that the service was running effectively and to provide managers with appropriate oversight, monitoring and assurance.
During the on-site assessment, documentation we were requesting to review was not always available or could not be located by managers. This included documentation in relation to the safety of the environment, meaning we were not fully assured that the service had all appropriate and necessary testing and reviews in place. We also observed that there were files and folders relating to governance that were either not up-to-date or were unorganised. It was therefore not clear how managers could be assured that the service was running in line with their expectations and in a safe manner.
The service did not have embedded systems and processes to ensure that it could run safely and effectively without the Registered Manager being on-site. The Registered Manager was responsible for the majority of the oversight and management of the service, although they had been restricted in how often they were on-site in the 6 months prior to the assessment. We identified issues during the inspection that the Registered Manager either did not appear to be aware of or had not yet addressed, meaning we were not fully assured that the processes and systems were working effectively at getting any issues resolved in a timely manner or that staff in the service were observing and escalating issues appropriately. For example, we found significant concerns related to the environment and it did not appear these had been acknowledged or escalated by staff and there was no evidence the Registered Manager was aware of these concerns, or was taking, or planning to take any action, prior to feedback from the inspection team.
Following the on-site assessment, we requested further information from the service to support our review and judgements. The service did not provide any of the information that we had requested due to unforeseen circumstances that impacted on the Registered Manager’s ability to fulfil the information requests. The Registered Manager had stated that they were the only one who would be able to respond to these requests to the CQC, although it was not clear why this was the case with having a staff team including a trainee manager on-site. Therefore, we were concerned that in the physical absence of the Registered Manager there was no clear governance oversight relating to the running of the service.
Partnerships and communities
We requested the contact details of any external stakeholders or organisations linked with the service as part of our information requests to the service following the on-site inspection. We asked for this information to enable us to gather feedback from these external stakeholders on their experiences of working with the service and the quality of the care and treatment that was provided. These contact details were not provided by the service due to unforeseen circumstances that impacted on the Registered Manager’s ability to fulfil the information requests. We have therefore not been able to gather this feedback.
Managers reported positive relationships with external stakeholders which included regular telephone contact with social workers and communicating electronically via videocalls with stakeholders as well. The Registered Manager noted that he had a positive relationship with the local authority and that they attended for reviews.
However, following the on-site inspection, we received some information that indicated that the provider was not always maintaining effective and positive relationships with external partners and stakeholders. This included instances where calls and emails to the service were not responded to or returned, along with not attending meetings or submitting information and data as required.
Learning, improvement and innovation
The service was a standalone unit with a small staff team. We were not made aware of or informed about any specific work or actions that managers and staff did to consider continuous learning, innovation or improvement within the service.