- GP practice
Church Langley Medical Centre
Assessment report published 26 September 2025
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Person-centred Care
- Care provision, Integration and continuity
- Providing Information
- Listening to and involving people
- Equity in access
- Equity in experiences and outcomes
- Planning for the future
Responsive
At the last inspection we rated the practice as Inadequate for providing responsive services because National GP Patient Survey results were below local and national averages and patients were not able to access appointments and treatment in a timely way. Complaints were not always used to improve the quality of care. The practice did not adequately seek and act on feedback from patients. At this inspection we found some improvements had been made to access; however, we continued to find concerns relating to how the practice handled complaints and provided information. Therefore, we have rated the practice as Requires Improvement for providing responsive services.
This service scored 50 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
Person-centred Care
We received a variety of mixed feedback from patients regarding receiving care tailored to their needs and centred around them as the patient. Patients who did not feel the practice provided person centred care told us at their last appointment, the doctor was more worried about the appointment being 10 minutes long and didn’t have time to check their notes or focus on the patient’s needs. One patient told us they were only offered a telephone appointment for their child despite the required appointment being a face-to-face appointment. When they challenged the practice, they were informed it was due to measles risk, which the patient had already been vaccinated against but the practice would not change or tailor the request to the patient’s needs. Whilst we saw negative feedback, we also found other patients were happy and felt staff went above and beyond to assist with their queries and the doctors took their time to explain everything. We also reviewed feedback received via NHS reviews and found one patient found nursing staff reassuring and positive when administering their vaccinations due to their phobia of needles.However, evidence from patient feedback showed the importance of flexibility, informed choice and continuity of care was not always reflected in the services provided.
Nursing roles included cytology, wound care, long-term condition reviews, immunisations and health promotion. They told us they used a patient centred approach by involving patients in their own health pathways and encouraging them to participate in their care plans. They told us they acted as advocates for patients if they discussed anything requiring this and they also checked for any welfare or safeguarding concerns and escalated or acted on findings. Staff told us that all calls and online requests were triaged and passed to the most relevant member of staff to manage. People had access to interpreters when required.
Care provision, Integration and continuity
Staff understood the diverse health and social care needs of their local communities and worked with external partners to ensure continuity of care and that services were flexible and joined up. Nursing staff described their integrated working with health visitors who attended their multidisciplinary meetings and they could see and send tasks to each other via their joint systems. They could also refer patients to the tissue viability team if required and could conduct joint appointments with them, following consent from the patient. GPs also told us there was increased efficiency with regards to undertaking long-term condition reviews at once rather than multiple consultations. They told us patients enjoyed this as they were given longer appointments. Staff told us engagement with the Primary Care Network (PCN) could be improved.
The practice worked in collaboration with the Hertfordshire and West Essex integrated care board (HWEICB), an integrated care system that brought together social care providers, local government, the NHS, community organisations and other partners to improve the lives of people living and working in their area. HWEICB reported good engagement with the practice. Their Contracts and Quality team worked with the practice when the practice requested their support.
There was a continuity of care policy which aimed to improve patient care, wellbeing, morbidity and mortality and coupled with reduced admissions, tests and referrals together with greater staff morale. We saw evidence of established links with services in the community including the multidisciplinary team, local authority and voluntary organisations for vulnerable patients. The lead GP was qualified in clinical dermatology, so the practice provided minor surgery services to both their patients and accepted inter practice referrals from other practices. Additional services were provided by their ARRS staff which included their inhouse paramedic. The practice did not look after any care homes but one of the GPs had a special interest in end-of-life care, so palliative care patients were monitored via a flag rated system and there was integrated working with the local hospice. However, continuity of care was not always reflected in the services provided as patients requiring an assessment from the GPs were not always able to do so and ended up using hospital services as highlighted in patient complaints. We were also not assured returning patients such as university students could access care provision when required. For example, one patient told us they faced significant obstacles trying to re-register to the practice and requesting a simple check after returning from university.
The practice carried out their own internal patient survey in 2024 and sent out 2,500 invitations by text message. 564 patients responded to this survey and results showed 22% of patients thought their experience was very good at the practice and 9% thought their experience was very poor. When we reviewed the 2024 GP National patient survey, we saw that 66% of patients responded positively to the overall experience of contacting their GP practice and this was comparable to the national average of 67%.We also received mixed feedback from various sources with regards to care provision. Some patients felt the practice provided an exceptional standard of care whilst some did not feel they received coordinated continuity of care. We received patient concerns regarding difficulties being referred to external services such as the leg ulcer clinic and some patients reported there was no continuity of care following hospital admission and for one patient, this led to a further hospital admission after their care was not followed up by the practice.We saw the practice displayed information about mental health and other health services in the practice. Their practice leaflet was displayed in the reception and offered various clinics and a self-referral barcode with access to external services such as counselling, sexual health clinic and smoking cessation support.
The practice had a housebound register of more than 40 patients, these patients could ring the practice anytime and they could access the rapid intervention team to carry out home visits to these patients. However, the practice also told us patients did not need to be on the housebound register to receive a home visit. Some patients were affected by the lack of continuity of care; for example, one young patient had a delay in receiving their medicines for a complex condition without a valid reason from the practice and they had not received a response from the practice after submitting a formal complaint.
Providing Information
There was mixed feedback in relation to providing information, as not all patients felt the information, they were given was accurate and up to date. Patients raised complaints with the practice about not being informed of diagnoses and test results and this was consistent with feedback sent to CQC. Some patients felt their consultations were rushed and this had an impact on the information they were provided regarding their treatment. We also received a patient complaint regarding data breaches of their personal data. Despite verified NHS reviews showing overall positive feedback from patients, negative reviews received 6 months prior reported frequent admin errors where they were given the incorrect forms to complete on 2 occasions, including information from the incorrect ICB after the practice sent a referral to the wrong ICB, delaying the patient’s care for 3 months. This happened on other occasions where information relating to a patient’s family member was sent to them in error. Other patients did not feel they were provided with clear and transparent information when it came to private fees and felt the charges were too expensive.
On the day of inspection, an Inspector spoke to 3 members of the patient participation group (PPG) whilst onsite. The members of the PPG told us they felt the way the practice worked with them could improve particularly around communication and transparency when sharing information. They held 4 meetings with the practice since January 2024 with 15 members in attendance. The members of the PPG expressed their desires for better engagement with the practice. They told us there was no chairperson and meetings were often short notice with just 24-hours’ notice and there was no mission statement, purpose, agenda or actions. They also wanted to work in partnership with the practice for action plan updates from the last inspection as they were mostly concerned with how the practice shared the information regarding the previous CQC report.
Positive feedback received where patients felt the non-clinical staff went above and beyond to help with queries relating to their annual review and their blood tests were communicated quickly and clearly. They also praised staff for acting speedily to help with any requests.
Staff were able to describe how they kept patient information secure and told us they used secure emails. Nursing staff told us they did not have remote access for home visits but they used printed sheets for home visits such as flu immunisations. Staff told us patients with communication needs for example, hard of hearing patients were noted on the system. Administration staff told us confidential waste was shredded in the practice.
We viewed the outstanding test results on their clinical system and found the practice was up to date with 16 test results, 7 of which were abnormal test results dated 6 November 2024, a day before the inspection. Following the identification of a large amount of unactioned and unscanned documents, a new member of staff had taken over this inherited backlog and workload and was doing additional overtime to try and combat the load. Multiple recruitment drives had been unsuccessful; however, going forward, the practice told us there would be a process in place which monitored the workflow closely and provided clear trigger points; for example, when there were more than 100 documents waiting, or if the designated member of staff was more than 2 days behind, so that backup plans could be implemented. These plans would be monitored via their risk register and would include holiday and sickness absences to avoid a future build-up of work.
We also observed how patient information was kept secure and how the practice supported patient care and treatment in line with the Accessible Information Standard (AIS); for example, there was a hearing loop in the practice and people who had difficulty with reading, writing and using digital services were supported with accessible information and this was in line with this policy. We saw the practice share minutes of meeting from their Patient Participation Group (PPG) on the practice website. The practice website had a language translate option with access to different languages. All relevant data protection and confidentiality policies were accessible on the practice website and we saw evidence of an access to medical records policy.
The practice made reasonable adjustments for disabled people. Interpreting and translation for people who did not speak English as a first language and for deaf people who used British Sign Language were available. However, there were gaps in the confidentiality and data protection policy provided by the practice. Although we found data protection and information governance was covered extensively in the staff handbook and there was a confidentiality and data protection statement, crucial information relating to named leads in these areas was not included. For example, the policy mentioned an information governance lead, data protection officer (DPO) and Caldicott guardian but did not name who the leads were which was usually senior staff in the practice. There was a risk that staff didn’t know the designated leads for ensuring all information was handled responsibly and in compliance with relevant regulations.
Listening to and involving people
Patient experience of the service as indicated in the 2024 National GP Patient Survey showed that 93% of patients felt involved in decisions about their care and treatment and this was comparable to the local and national averages of 91%. We also received feedback from patients via complaints sent to CQC and as part of patient feedback on care we requested as part of this inspection. Feedback received from some showed they did not always feel they received information about their care and treatment or have appropriate support to make decisions. We found this was the case for 16 of the 40 patients who shared feedback or raised concerns with CQC. The practice carried out their own internal patient survey in 2024 and sent out 2,500 invitations by text message. 564 patients responded to this survey and results showed 40% of patient thought the last time they had an appointment at the practice, healthcare professional was very good at listening to them and 3% thought the healthcare professional was very poor at listening to them.
We received a variety of mixed patient feedback with regards to feeling listened to; for example, some patients told us their medical concerns were not listened to and dismissed. Nine of the 40 complaints sent to CQC were from concerns that had not been resolved by the practice. Patients told us the practice did not respond to their formal complaints and could not access management to discuss their concerns. Patients also told us they observed staff reluctance to escalate concerns at reception. One patient felt a GP was standoffish and dismissive when trying to access care for them and their family. We also received positive feedback where patients told us they felt understood and listened to during their appointments and the practice responded well to feedback. The practice provided evidence to show improved patient engagement with practice surveys. For example, 210 patients participated in the 2022 survey and in 2024, this had increased to 564 patients.
Following the last inspection, the provider wanted to make the complaints process more streamlined, so they now had a complaints manager who was also the reception operations manager, to address and respond and investigate issues in a timely manner. They also introduced online complaints form and told us there was a quick turnaround of investigations. The practice was proud of positive feedback received. Staff told us complaints were managed through practice index.Nursing staff told us that in response to patient feedback, a blocked on the day slot was added to each nurse for patients who called and required urgent nurse appointments such as for wound care or tetanus injection. However, not all staff were made aware of improvements made following complaints investigations, nor could they share examples of any recent complaints and this was for 4 staff we spoke to.
There were some evidence where complaints were used to drive improvement; however, this was not always consistently applied, as it was not clear what action was taken to resolve some complaints and how improvements would be made. The practice had a complaints policy; however, the information regarding the new complaints lead who reported to the practice manager was not reflected in this policy. We saw evidence that patients could share feedback and raise complaints about their care and the practice collated all the NHS reviews. We saw information on how to make a complaint was displayed in the practice and on their website.Although the practice had taken steps to improve the complaints processes, further improvement and monitoring was required to ensure all complaints received were acknowledged, acted on and completed in a timely manner as per patient feedback. This was also consistent with the practice acknowledging their error at missing a patient’s complaint in their written response to them.
We were also not assured the processes for people raising complaints on behalf of other patients were being effectively followed. For example, the complaints procedure stated that complaints could be made on behalf of the patient where that patient by reason of physical capacity could not make it themselves. This applied to one complaint raised in September 2024 that we reviewed, where the family member was told by the practice that they could not raise a complaint on behalf of a patient who met these criteria. However, the complaints policy stated in such cases where a third party was pursuing a complaint on behalf of the person affected, the provider would request amongst others contact details of the affected person so that they can be contacted for confirmation that they consent to the third party acting on their behalf. However, in this case procedure had not been followed as the provider did not contact the patient themselves as per procedure to confirm but told the person raising the complaint that they would respond if in future the patient raised the complaint, despite being incapacitated at the time. As a result, the complaint was not investigated and resolved in a timely manner until the inspection, 3 months after the complaint was raised.
During the inspection, we discussed complaints sent to CQC and asked the practice to investigate these complaints and follow up with the patients. Whilst the practice was responsive and showed evidence of patient engagement, not all patients were satisfied with how the practice managed their complaints. For example, some felt the practice had not addressed the entirety of their complaints and at least 5 complainants felt the information provided by the practice to themselves and to CQC had been inaccurate leaving their complaints unresolved. These concerns were sent to the practice to follow up with the patients affected.The practice submitted 35 complaints received since January 2024 via their complaints log. When we reviewed these complaints, we found some had been resolved; however, we were not assured of the effectiveness of their investigations when some of these complaints relating to missed diagnoses were not upheld by the practice. Following a complaint about the waiting time to call the practice, the practice improved by implementing a new callback system.
Equity in access
The practice carried out their own internal patient survey in 2024 and sent out 2,500 invitations by text message and 564 responses were received. Results showed 13% of patients found it easy to get through to the practice and 25% of patients thought it was not at all easy to get through to the practice. 18% thought it was very good making an appointment and 15% of patients thought it was very poor making an appointment.
The results from the 2024 National GP patient survey showed 349 surveys were sent out and 99 responses were received. This was a lower response rate to that of the practice’s own internal survey. However, the 2024 National GP survey was compared against the expected averages locally and nationally. In this survey, the practice was significantly below the expected averages and were a negative outlier in 3 of the indicators relating to access. For example, results showed 17% of patients found it easy to get through to someone at the practice on the phone and this was significantly lower than the expected average of 50%. 51% of patients were satisfied with the appointments they were offered and this was lower than the expected average of 72%. 27% responded positively to the overall experience of making an appointment and this was lower than the expected average of 53%.
They also carried out their friends and family test survey and the February and April, Oct 2024 survey showed felt they were dealt with quickly and efficiently and their appointments were on time with efficient doctors and although July 2024 survey results showed patients felt clinicians were running late for appointments and results from the February, July and August 2024 survey showed the service was prompt and staff were on time; however, they thought there were lengthy waits to access the practice via phone.
We also reviewed feedback sent to CQC and saw mixed feedback. Patients were generally satisfied with access. Patients told us they found the new callback option useful and effective and found the check in system for appointments easy and they were seen on time. They also praised the practice’s fast online response. We also reviewed verified NHS reviews showed patients were mostly happy with access and next day follow up appointments. Some patients also reported they were fit in last minute and the appointments were on time, whilst negative feedback related to late running of appointments and having to wait a few weeks for appointments. Some patients experience of making an appointment was negative due to being told go to go accident and emergency due to the practice reaching capacity. Negative feedback was received from some patients who reported no face-to-face appointments were available for children but only telephone appointments.
They carried out their friends and family test surveys and the results for July 2024 showed patients felt it was nice to have a face to face appointment; however, results from March 2024 test survey patients felt appointment availability with a doctor was an area of improvement, whilst in May 2024, patients said they would like to be able to book appointments with the nurses and healthcare assistant's up to 12 weeks in advance. Patients fedback in their October 2024 friends and family test survey that the flu clinics were well run.
The practice acknowledged the survey results regarding telephone access and told us this remained their priority to improve. They told us patients struggled with the 8am rush and some patients were unaware or willing to use the online methods. They also told us patients traditionally used to access medical help by calling the surgery and could still ring the practice or request appointments online. Staff told us they tried to accommodate as many urgent patient requests as possible on the day. They told us video and telephone consultations were available. The provider also told us there was a big push to reduce did not attend (DNA) appointments.The Herts and West Essex integrated care board (HWEICB) told us the practice had access to improvement plans and were working towards Modern General Practice. The only issue was some additional functionality for the cloud-based telephony which they were working through with the procurement hub.
Practice open times were displayed on the practice leaflet and website. During the inspection, we saw that 13 patients had used the online appointment system and there was 1 routine appointment available for that same day and the following Monday. The practice website made self-referrals and online services easier to use and they were advertised on their Jayex board and Facebook page.
Same day appointments were available for urgent appointments. There was a duty GP who reviewed the triage list initially seen by the reception staff in the afternoon and contacted patients. The practice was closed for 1 hour each day to facilitate staff training. Patients had access to the online form during this time, they could still attend the practice in person to complete an appointment form; however, urgent medical needs that could not wait an hour would be signposted to accident and emergency. In 2022, the practice introduced an internet-based telephone system allowing more lines. There was further improved telephone system further by using services such as automated call back options, which had the ability to monitor and audit for improvement purposes. Patients could also be referred to their extended hours service operated by Stella Healthcare.We saw improvements made to access. The practice carried out an evaluation of the GP patient survey and since it was undertaken, the telephone system was further upgraded in early October 2024 and a survey was planned for December 2024 to capture patient feedback. The practice also carried out an appointment audit which showed in April 2023, 3453 appointments were offered and in April 2024, 5000 appointments were offered. The practice employed more staff across the different staff groups. Nursing staff were given longer appointments for wound dressings, which increased from 10-minute slots to 20-minute slots
Equity in experiences and outcomes
Not all patients felt they were treated equally. A patient told us about their experience of using the service, the issue of stigma in mental health and the need for staff awareness. One patient told us they experienced an exacerbation of their mental health condition whenever they encountered one of the GPs and they found it hard to obtain their medication. Another patient told us they were happy with the new tech to assist patients because they could receive advice whilst in bed and have their prescriptions sent to their chosen pharmacy.
Staff told us they respected and appreciated people’s backgrounds and cultural values and received training in equality and diversity. Patients were informed that chaperones were available. Staff who acted as a chaperone had completed training. A chaperone is an impartial observer present during an examination or consultation when a patient may feel vulnerable, for example during an intimate examination. A chaperone acts to protect both patients and staff. Homeless patients could register with the practice and walk in for their appointments. They also catered for migrant families and displayed notices in Afghan language, whilst interpreters were also available. They also registered patients in vulnerable circumstances and they were coded in a different way.
There were processes in place to prevent inequality and experience and outcomes. There was an equality and diversity policy which aimed to design and implement policies and procedures that met the diverse needs of their service, patients and workforce, ensuring none were placed at a disadvantage over others, in accordance with the Equality Act 2010. The practice mission statement objectives which were available on their website also stated they will never refuse to accept a patient for care at this practice because of their race, colour, sexual orientation or disability. We saw staff treating people with dignity and respect. The practice website had links on how to access support and information on finances, housing, children and relationships
The practice held vulnerable patient registers; for example, they had a register of 37 patients diagnosed with learning disability and there were designated staff to ensure these patients received their reviews. Learning disability patients were offered 40-minute appointments and they were contacted a few times a year. The practice also had carers registers which included young carers. Their register for young carers listed 10 young carers managed by the GP assistant.
Planning for the future
We did not receive specific examples from people about planning for the future.
There was a palliative care lead GP who worked with the palliative care nurse. Monthly meetings took place together with the hospice to discuss end of life patients and plan visits. Staff told us they regularly attended multidisciplinary team (MDT) meetings where they discussed patients who received end-of-life care.The practice had a succession plan in place. Leaders told us they updated their partnership agreement and were planning an increase in partnership.
The practice did not look after any care homes but people who may be approaching the end of their life were identified. One of the GPs had a special interest in end-of-life care, so palliative care patients were monitored via a flag rated system and there was integrated working with the local hospice. We reviewed their consent, Mental Capacity Act (MCA) and Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (DNACPR) policies and found them to be up to date and relevant to current national guidelines. We reviewed 2 DNACPR records and found although discussions had taken place with the patient and their families, the documentation was incomplete and did not contain all the required signage to ensure its effectiveness.
We saw evidence that information regarding their vulnerable population was shared with other services and staff.We saw evidence of end-of-life discussions via their MDT meeting minutes. The practice told us that 98 of their patients were on the end-of-life pathway and their appointments were booked at time to suit the patient and family.For example, we saw evidence of the practice respecting a patient’s wishes when they expressed they did not want to be placed on the end-of-life pathway. Despite clinicians agreeing the best action was for the patient to remain on the pathway, they respected the patient’s wishes and kept them under review. We also saw evidence of complex care patients providing consent for referrals to social care.