• Doctor
  • GP practice

Castlegate & Derwent Surgery

Overall: Inadequate read more about inspection ratings

Isel Road, Cockermouth, Cumbria, CA13 9HT (01900) 705750

Provided and run by:
Castlegate & Derwent Surgery

Assessment report published 4 June 2025

On this page

Well-led

Requires improvement

27 May 2025

Non-clinical leaders were visible, knowledgeable and supportive, helping staff develop in their roles. However, there were ongoing issues within the established clinical team. The practice had begun to improve governance.

This service scored 39 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Shared direction and culture

Score: 1

The service did not have a clear shared vision, strategy and open culture which was based on transparency, equity, equality and engagement which was reflected across the entire service. Some staff told us the practice had a clear vision, while others told us they did not know what this was. The practice team did not always understand the challenges and the needs of people and their communities, and leadership acknowledged they needed to carry out a comprehensive assessment of their patient population to identify those most at risk. At our last assessment we saw a lack of succession planning and business strategy, at this assessment the provider shared an analysis of the practice which highlighted areas of risk, areas of improvement and strengths. This was a new piece of work and while we acknowledge the positive change, we did not see evidence of these improvements being embedded within practice at the time of our assessment.

Staff told us they were aware of conflict and issues within the established clinical team. This team was not working effectively together to create a positive, inclusive, and supportive culture. The lack of cohesion within the partnership was impacting the overall morale within the practice.

Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders

Score: 2

Not all leaders understood the context in which the service delivered care, treatment and support. They did not always embody the culture and values of their workforce and organisation. Leaders did not always have the skills, knowledge, experience and credibility to lead effectively, or they did not always do so with integrity, openness and honesty.

The ongoing conflicts within the senior clinical team demonstrated that clinical leadership had a closed culture, leaders were unable to provide evidence that this conflict would be resolved.

Staff feedback in relation to the practice manager was very positive, and evidenced clear improvements that had been made over the last three months.

Staff told us the practice manager was approachable and responded to some concerns raised. Staff told us at our last inspection and told us once again that they felt there was nothing in place to protect them if a patient was rude or aggressive. Staff also told us some members of leadership modelled the values of the practice,. We saw the leadership team worked with other practices in the primary care network.

Freedom to speak up

Score: 2

Staff members did not always feel they could speak up and that their voice would be heard. Since our last assessment the practice had appointed an external freedom to speak up guardian as well as a person within the practice. Staff were aware of how to raise concerns, and we saw examples where staff had used the arrangements in place to positive effect. However, we received feedback which indicated staff had raised issues and felt their concerns had not been acted upon in an appropriate manner. We saw evidence that staff had all been given the opportunity of a meeting with a senior partner following our last inspection. Staff told us they sometimes felt forced into changing working days or working overtime.

Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion

Score: 2

The service did not always work towards an inclusive and fair culture by improving equality and equity for people who work for them.

Policies and procedures to promote diversity and equality were in place. In some cases adjustments had been made to ensure all staff were valued, for example we saw adjustments to support staff who required extra support and adaptations. However, some staff told us they did not feel leadership had been supportive at times when it was needed. The ongoing conflict within the partnership led to a lack of an inclusive culture at senior level. We spoke with external stakeholders who continued to have concerns in relation to this conflict.

Governance, management and sustainability

Score: 1

The service did not always have clear responsibilities, roles, systems of accountability or good governance. They did not always act on the best information about risk, performance and outcomes, or share this securely with others when appropriate. There was a lack of regular and structured clinical supervision for staff who required it.

Managers had ensured appraisals and performance reviews were undertaken when required, as well as oversee regular meetings such as 'partner meetings' and 'significant events meetings' . The practice manager had begun to establish governance processes that were appropriate for their service. Staff could access all required policies and procedures. Managers had commenced regular practice meetings with staff, during which they discussed clinical concerns and emerging risks. Managers clearly recorded any actions arising from these meetings and ensured they shared these with staff. Staff took patient confidentiality and information security seriously. There was a lack of oversight of trainees within the practice, members of leadership provided different evidence of the structure of a trainee programme within the practice.

Many improvements were within very early stages at the time of this site visit.

Partnerships and communities

Score: 2

The leadership within the practice told us that they had implemented a new way of providing care to care home patients. We received positive feedback from two of the care homes in relation to new approach, and both spoke positively of the paramedic who visited. External partners and stakeholders continued to have concerns about the practice.

Learning, improvement and innovation

Score: 1

The service did not always focus on continuous learning, innovation and improvement across the organisation and local system. They did not always encourage creative ways of delivering equality of experience, outcome and quality of life for people. They did not always actively contribute to safe, effective practice and research.

The practice had implemented a total triage model one month prior to our site visit, and management were looking at ways to improve this regularly, staff told us however that concerns raised in relation to this system had not been addressed by leadership in a way that meant they felt listened to.

Staff told us that they were given opportunities to attend external training and were encouraged to do so. Leaders highlighted due to the difficulty in recruiting new staff, it had been a priority to up skill staff.

The practice provided some evidence of audits, including one relating to Hormone Replacement Therapy which was on going at the time of our assessment. However other audits provided were not a full two cycle completed audit which would enable us to see clear evidence of improved patient outcomes. We saw evidence that learning from significant events had taken over a year to be shared with staff, processes were not embedded to ensure that learning had been understood and was carried out in practice.