- Homecare service
Butterflies Care & Support Ltd
We served 2 warning notices on Butterflies Care & Support Ltd on 11 June 2026 for failing to meet the regulations related to safe care and treatment and good governance at Butterflies Care & Support Ltd.
Assessment report published 29 June 2026
Contents
On this page
- Overview
- Assessing needs
- Delivering evidence-based care and treatment
- How staff, teams and services work together
- Supporting people to live healthier lives
- Monitoring and improving outcomes
- Consent to care and treatment
Effective
Effective – this means we looked for evidence that people’s care, treatment and support achieved good outcomes and promoted a good quality of life, based on best available evidence. At our last assessment we rated this key question requires improvement. At this assessment the rating has remained requires improvement. This meant the effectiveness of people’s care, treatment and support did not always achieve good outcomes or was inconsistent.
This service scored 50 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.
Assessing needs
The registered managers did not always ensure people’s needs were fully assessed or that care and treatment were planned effectively. Initial assessments relied heavily on information from external professionals and did not always include detailed information about people’s health, wellbeing, communication or medicine needs. This meant important information may not have been fully understood or recorded before care started.
Care planning was not always clearly linked to assessments. Records did not consistently show how assessed needs had been translated into clear care plans for staff to follow. Some care records lacked detail, particularly in relation to clinical needs, which increased the risk that care may not be delivered safely or consistently.
Reviews of care were not carried out regularly or consistently. There was limited evidence that people or relatives were involved in reviewing care or that their views were used to update support plans. This meant changes in people’s needs may not have been recognised or responded to in a timely way.
Systems to monitor the quality and effectiveness of assessments and care planning were not in place. Audits were not carried out, so the provider could not identify gaps or drive improvement.
However, there were examples where the provider had used information from external professionals to help inform care such as advice from district nurses, which showed some understanding of the importance of partnership working.
Delivering evidence-based care and treatment
Care and treatment were not always planned and delivered in line with current guidance or best practice. Care plans were not detailed enough. This meant staff did not always have clear information to provide safe and effective care. Guidance within care records did not consistently reflect current legislation or best practice, which increased the risk of inconsistent practice.
There was limited oversight of how care was delivered. Monitoring of staff practice against expected standards was not robust and was mainly based on informal telephone conversations rather than structured checks or observations. This meant the provider could not assure themselves that care was being delivered safely or in line with best practice. Training did not always support staff to deliver evidence-based care. Some staff had not received updates to reflect current standards.
Despite these concerns, there were examples of the registered managers working with people and relatives to plan care and respond to changes. One relative said, “Both [registered managers] came down to see me when my [family member] was in hospital and we realised we needed a different plan of action for when they came out. So, they came to my house and we discussed how to manage my [family member’s] situation and it was then that they suggested we might need to bring in another agency to do the third visit and weekends and bank holidays and that has worked quite well. I don't worry so much about my [family member] and I know that if I do go away, they will be well looked after.”
How staff, teams and services work together
The provider worked with external services to help meet people’s needs, including during periods of change. Staff and the registered managers showed an understanding of the importance of joint working to support continuity of care.
Records of communication and partnership working were limited. There was not always written evidence to show how decisions were made. Systems for recording joint working were not robust, which meant it was not always clear how care was coordinated or reviewed across services.
Despite this, people and relatives gave positive feedback about how services worked together in practice. One relative said, “My [family member] has 2 [care] visits a day in the morning and then at lunchtime. We needed to increase the care and introduce an evening visit but Butterflies care weren't able to offer that extra visit as they were at full capacity and so we have a different agency who do the evening visit. The 2 agencies do seem to work quite well together. They don't leave written notes for each other, but both agencies keep records although only Butterflies keep a paper copy in the folder. They normally communicate through me, so I coordinate all the care.”
Supporting people to live healthier lives
The registered managers did not always support people to manage their health and wellbeing or take action to reduce future care needs. The registered managers did not consistently recognise or respond to risks that could affect people’s health. Concerns such as addiction were not always escalated or referred to appropriate professionals. This meant opportunities to improve people’s wellbeing and reduce risks were missed. Links with external services were not always effective and there was limited evidence of coordinated action to support healthier outcomes.
Support for healthy living was inconsistent. Some people received advice and support, but this was not provided to everyone in a structured or planned way. There was limited evidence of actions to actively promote wellbeing, independence or long-term health improvement. Care records did not always show how staff supported people to make informed choices about their health.
However, people told us they were supported with their day-to-day nutrition and hydration needs. One relative said, “They get my [family member] their breakfast, although they usually have the same thing every day but [staff] always ask. [Staff] make them a drink and always give 2 large drinking bottles full of water that they leave [on the side] and the water is changed at lunchtime and then again later on.” A person told us, “[Staff] always ask me which meal I'd like to have and they make me a drink and leave me with a drink.”
Monitoring and improving outcomes
Systems to monitor care or improve outcomes for people were not effective as records were not routinely reviewed to identify patterns or concerns. People’s care and treatment was not routinely reviewed to ensure they met expected outcomes. There were no audits or quality checks in place to assess the safety or quality of care being delivered. Performance data was not collected or analysed, which meant risks were not identified, understood or acted upon.
Staff were not clear about how outcomes for people were measured or how improvements should be made. There were no action plans to address concerns or drive improvement. Where issues had been identified, there was no evidence of follow up or learning to prevent reoccurrence.
The registered managers did not have clear oversight of the service. There was no structured approach to monitoring performance or reviewing standards of care. The lack of monitoring systems meant the provider could not demonstrate continuous improvement. Outcomes for people were not evaluated against clinical expectations or people’s own goals, and there was no evidence of service development or learning to improve people’s experiences.
Consent to care and treatment
Systems to record and review consent were in place but were not always robust. Although people had signed to agree to their care, records did not show ongoing discussions about consent or how decisions were reviewed over time. There was limited evidence of how changes in people’s wishes or circumstances were revisited and documented.
Staff understood the importance of promoting choice. People had the mental capacity to make their own decisions and had made plans such as agreeing a Lasting Power of Attorney for if the time came where they could no longer make decisions for themselves. Some people had also confirmed their wishes for life saving medical treatment. People had all signed consent to their care being delivered. People reported staff always sought their consent before undertaking any care.
People told us staff respected their choices and supported them to make decisions about their care. People said they were supported to maintain control over day-to-day decisions and staff checked with them before providing care. One relative told us, “They come for the full hour and sometimes they even stay beyond the hour. They assist my [family member] to get dressed and all the staff give them the choice of what to wear. They understand they are able to make decisions like that for themselves.”