• Care Home
  • Care home

Archived: Alternative House Care Home Blackburn

Overall: Requires improvement read more about inspection ratings

548 Preston Old Road, Blackburn, Lancashire, BB2 5NL (01254) 200411

Provided and run by:
Ms Catherine Blyth

Important:

We served a warning notice on Ms Catherine Blyth on 15 April 2025 for failing to meet the regulations related to Regulation 17, (1) (2) (a) (b) (c) (f) Good governance  at Alternative House Care Home Blackburn, 548 Preston Old Road, Blackburn, BB2 5NL

Assessment report published 9 September 2025

On this page

Safe

Requires improvement

9 September 2025

Safe – this means we looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm.

At our last assessment we rated this key question requires improvement. At this assessment the rating has remained requires improvement. This meant some aspects of the service were not always safe and there was limited assurance about safety. There was an increased risk that people could be harmed.

The service was in continued breach of legal regulations in relation to medicines and fit and proper persons employed.

This service scored 53 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Learning culture

Score: 2

The provider did not consistently have a proactive and positive culture of safety. Lessons were not consistently learnt to identify and embed good practice. We saw repeated concerns from our previous assessment which have been identified in this report. For example, some care plans required further information to support staff to deliver safe care. One person at the service had a specific health condition. There was no written guidance to inform staff on the signs and symptoms which the person may display if they became unwell. There was no instruction for staff on the action to take if the persons health changed. We also noted information on the persons mobility needs was contradictory. In one part of the care record, we saw equipment was needed to help the person mobilise. In another part of the care record, we saw the person did not require equipment to mobilise.

We reviewed a further person’s care record which recorded the equipment they needed to maintain their safety at night. Staff told us, and we saw, the person was using different equipment at the time of our assessment. The care records were provided to us a week after we saw the different equipment the person was using. We also noted contradictory information regarding how to attach a sling to a hoist.

Records showed a person at the home had experienced a fall and this had not been captured by the corresponding falls audit. There was no evidence to show this had been reviewed to identify lessons learned.

However, staff we spoke with knew how to report accidents and incidents and how this should be done. Staff told us if changes were needed to people’s care, this was passed to them through handovers and discussions, and audits and checks were carried out to identify if there were any lessons learned.

We saw accident forms were completed and the deputy manager told us these were reviewed to identify any themes or trends. For example, a person chose to walk without their mobility aid, and this increased their risk of falls. Additional safety equipment was introduced to minimise the risk of falls.

Safe systems, pathways and transitions

Score: 2

The provider did not always work well with people and healthcare partners to establish and maintain safe systems of care. They did not always make sure there was continuity of care, including when people moved between different services.

We reviewed one person’s ‘hospital passport’ and saw this did not contain the specific diet they required. This is a document that provides essential information to staff who may be unfamiliar with the person’s needs. This placed the person at risk of avoidable harm as the written documentation which was to be provided if the person went to hospital, was incorrect. This posed the risk that the person’s needs would not be met. Prior to the assessment concluding, the provider told us they had addressed this.

Prior to people moving into the service, a pre-admission assessment was carried out to ensure the service could meet people’s needs. Relatives told us if their family member needed support from a health professional, this was arranged and documentation we saw evidenced this.

Safeguarding

Score: 2

The provider did not always work with people and healthcare partners to understand what being safe meant to them and the best way to achieve that. They did not always concentrate on improving people’s lives while protecting their right to live in safety, free from bullying, harassment, abuse, discrimination, avoidable harm and neglect.

We reviewed one person’s care records and saw a letter which advised their Deprivation of Liberty authorisation had lapsed. The provider told us they had submitted a renewal form to the correct supervisory authority, and we asked the provider to send us evidence of this. This information was not received by us. Therefore, we cannot be assured the person was lawfully deprived of their liberty.

Staff were able to confidently explain the reasons they may make a safeguarding referral to the safeguarding authority and how they would do this.

Involving people to manage risks

Score: 3

The provider worked with people to understand and manage risks by thinking holistically. Staff provided care to meet people’s needs that was safe, supportive and enabled people to do the things that mattered to them.

Risk assessments were in place to identify if people were at risk of falls, malnutrition and to assess the risk of people developing pressure damage to their skin. These were reviewed when required and risk controls were in place if needed. For example, we saw equipment provided by external stakeholders was used to support people’s safety. The provider and manager told us they reviewed risk assessments as people’s needs changed.

We reviewed a care record which evidenced a person had been supported to understand the risk of mobilising alone. A further person shared how staff had discussed the risks of using a specific piece of equipment. They said, “They’ve told me about what could go wrong, and I accept it.”

Safe environments

Score: 2

The provider did not always detect and control potential risks in the care environment.

We viewed a gas safety certificate and saw this had expired. The provider told us they had requested this work to be carried out but had not heard from the gas safety engineer. They took immediate action to ensure the work was carried out before the assessment concluded and provided us with evidence of this.

A weighing scale had not been calibrated; this meant we could not be assured it was accurate when used. In addition, one area of the basement was used by staff to access some medicines and had no working light for the first two days of the assessment visit which placed staff at risk of falls. The provider told us they had contacted an electrician and were waiting for the work to be completed. This was rectified before the assessment concluded.

 

We saw evidence that fire equipment, lifting equipment and electrical safety checks were completed as required by regulation.

Safe and effective staffing

Score: 2

The provider made sure there were enough qualified, skilled and experienced staff.

The provider had not recruited any staff since the last assessment so we could not assess if the provider had improved their recruitment processes. We will check this at the next assessment. Therefore, the score for this quality statement will remain the same.

One staff member told us they felt an additional staff member would be beneficial as they would be able to spend more time with people and a relative commented, “Too many duties for too little people. Laundry, food, cleaning, care. How is that possible with so few staff.” Other relatives voiced no concerns with the staffing arrangements.

However, the provider used a dependency tool to help assess the number of staff required to support people. People told us they were satisfied with the response from staff and during the assessment we saw call bells were answered swiftly. One person commented, “No one hurries me.” On one occasion we noted the lounge was left unattended. We discussed this with the deputy manager who told us some people who used the lounge had call bells and would use these if they or anyone else in the lounge needed support. The provider told us that staff checked people’s well-being frequently and we saw this being carried out.

We reviewed supervision and appraisal records and found staff had not consistently had supervision in line with the providers expectations. We discussed this with the deputy manager who acknowledged this and said there was now a plan in place to ensure staff received regular supervisions. Staff we spoke with confirmed this and we saw documentation which evidenced supervisions were being carried out.

Staff told us they had effective support and development opportunities. Staff said they completed online training to maintain their knowledge. However, one staff member could not explain their understanding of the Deprivation of Liberty safeguards and we received conflicting information from staff on the procedure to take if there was a fire. Before the assessment concluded, the provider told us they had taken action to support staff knowledge.

Infection prevention and control

Score: 2

The provider did not always manage the risk of infection. They did not always detect and control the risk of it spreading.

At the last assessment we had concerns with the management of the risk of infection. At this assessment we saw some improvements had been made. People’s rooms were clean and hygienic, and we saw the kitchen and equipment was clean and well organised. Food was stored appropriately and dated on opening. This helps ensure food remains safe to eat.

However, we noted a communal shower room required cleaning with a build-up of black marking in some areas and an item of reuseable equipment was unclean. The laundry area was cluttered with a build-up of dust and items. This does not promote a hygienic environment and could impact effective cleaning. Prior to the assessment concluding we saw the reusable equipment and communal shower room had been cleaned and work had started on the laundry area to declutter and clean it.

Staff had access to personal protective equipment and we observed staff using this appropriately.

Medicines optimisation

Score: 2

The provider did not always make sure that medicines were managed safely. At our last assessment we had concerns regarding the safe management of medicines. During this assessment we identified shortfalls in practice. We saw occasions when the medicine keys were hidden in an unsecure drawer in an unlocked and unstaffed office. The staff administering medicines told us this was normal practice. This posed the risk that medicines were accessible to unauthorised people.

People did not always have detailed written instruction on their ‘as required’ medicines. There was insufficient information to guide staff on why the medicine had been prescribed.

For one medicine we found the balance of the medicine did not match the balance of what would be expected if the person had received their medicines as prescribed.

We observed staff did not always follow best practice when storing and administering controlled drugs. Controlled drugs are medicines that have stricter controls to ensure they are stored and used safely. We noted some controlled drugs in boxes were stored in a medicines trolley and not in a controlled drug cupboard. This was not in line with best practice guidance and their own policy. The staff member told us this had been placed there temporarily on the day of our assessment. In addition, we also noted when a controlled drug was administered, a second staff was not in the area to witness this as required by best practice guidance. The inspector intervened before the medicine was administered to ensure the correct process was followed.

Although we did not identify any harm because of the concerns we identified, we could not be assured that people received their medicines safely as prescribed. This placed people at risk of harm. Prior to the assessment concluding, the manager implemented further audits to help identify shortfalls and support the safe management of medicines.