• Hospice service

St Michael's Hospice

Overall: Outstanding read more about inspection ratings

Bartestree, Hereford, Herefordshire, HR1 4HA (01432) 851000

Provided and run by:
St Michael's Hospice (Incorporating The Freda Pearce Foundation)

Assessment report published 9 November 2026

On this page

Safe

Outstanding

14 October 2026

We looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm.

At our last assessment we rated this key question good. At this assessment the rating has changed to outstanding.

This meant people were protected by a strong and distinctive approach to safeguarding, including positive risk-taking to maximise their control over their lives. People were fully involved, and the provider was open and transparent when things went wrong.

This service scored 91 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Learning culture

Score: 4

Staff understood their responsibilities in relation to incident reporting and could describe how they reported incidents, near misses and safety concerns. Incidents were reviewed through established governance processes and leaders considered themes and trends to identify wider learning rather than viewing incidents in isolation. Learning from incidents, complaints and audits was shared through team meetings, newsletters, a quarterly quality improvement bulletin, and supervision sessions. Staff gave examples of changes that had been implemented following incidents and feedback, demonstrating that learning was embedded into practice.

Staff demonstrated an understanding of Duty of Candour and described how they were open and honest with patients and relatives when things went wrong.

Leaders maintained effective oversight of incidents through weekly incident review meetings. New and ongoing incidents were reviewed, graded according to their level of risk and impact, and discussed to identify any themes, trends, or learning opportunities. Actions arising from incidents were allocated to named individuals, with clear timescales for completion. Leaders monitored progress against these actions to ensure they were completed promptly and that lessons learned were embedded into practice to reduce the risk of recurrence.

The value of learning was continually demonstrated and reinforced by leaders. Leaders went beyond simply sharing learning and actively embedded a culture of curiosity and continual improvement. Staff at all levels were encouraged to lead improvement initiatives, participate in audits, and service development projects. Leaders regularly reflected on learning from both positive outcomes and adverse events and used this to shape strategic priorities. Staff consistently told us that learning was valued, improvement ideas were acted upon, and feedback resulted in meaningful change, demonstrating a culture where learning was continually reinforced and owned by everyone in the hospice.

Staff told us they felt supported following incidents and had access to debriefing, psychological interventions and wellbeing support where required. Evidence showed the hospice actively sought to improve the quality and safety of care through reflection, learning and continuous improvement.

Safe systems, pathways and transitions

Score: 4

Leaders promoted a culture in which transitions were viewed as an important part of people's overall care experience. Processes for admission and discharge supported continuity of care and helped ensure patients received care in the setting most appropriate to their needs. The service worked closely with patients, relatives and partner organisations to support safe transitions between services and minimise disruption to care.

The service had effective systems and processes to ensure referrals, admissions, transfers and discharges were managed safely. Routine referrals for inpatient and Hospice at Home services were accepted 365 days a year and were usually received in writing, enabling staff to gather detailed information about people's needs, risks and circumstances. Healthcare professionals could also make urgent referrals by telephone when a more timely response was required. For example, staff accepted urgent referrals from acute hospitals when people were recognised to be entering the dying phase and required rapid access to a hospice bed or support at home. This helped ensure people received care in their preferred place of death whenever possible.

Staff worked collaboratively with system partners to monitor patients waiting for admission and ensure those with the greatest need received timely access to care. Daily multidisciplinary discussions were held with organisations across the local health system, including acute hospitals, district nursing services and community cancer nurse specialists. These discussions enabled staff to identify changes in people's needs and prioritise admissions appropriately.

The service employed dedicated admission and discharge nurses who managed patient pathways and supported safe transitions of care. This provided clear coordination throughout a person's journey and helped ensure admissions, transfers and discharges were planned, timely and responsive to changing needs. Coordinators discussed admission and discharge arrangements with patients and their relatives before admission so they understood what to expect from the service and the possible outcomes of hospice care.

Staff recognised that some people's conditions could stabilise during admission, meaning specialist inpatient hospice care was no longer the most appropriate setting. Patients and those important to them were informed of this possibility early in their stay. This helped manage expectations and supported safe, coordinated discharge planning, reducing the risk of distress for people and their families.

The service also employed a dedicated nurse who worked closely with local care homes to support safe and effective transitions of care. This role provided additional oversight and continuity for people moving between hospice and care home settings. The nurse facilitated timely discharges, ensured care home staff had the information and resources required to meet people's needs safely, and maintained regular contact following discharge. This helped maintain continuity of care, enabled early identification of deterioration and ensured prompt access to specialist support when required. Where appropriate, staff could arrange GP review or readmission to the hospice, helping ensure people received care in the setting best suited to their changing needs.

The hospice demonstrated a proactive approach to discharge planning for people returning home. Staff completed home assessments and access visits to identify risks and ensure people could return home safely where this was their preference. Follow-up visits were undertaken after discharge to help people settle back into their home environment. Strong relationships with partner organisations enabled equipment and support services to be arranged without unnecessary delay, helping to reduce the risk of avoidable deterioration or hospital admission.

Occupational therapists were integrated within multidisciplinary team discussions and reviewed new admissions proactively to identify needs at an early stage. Staff worked closely with physiotherapists and other healthcare professionals to ensure assessments, care planning and interventions were coordinated around people's individual needs.

Staff maintained strong links with community services and specialist teams through a shared electronic patient record system. Information sharing was timely and appropriate, enabling professionals to respond quickly to changing needs. As a result, people experienced coordinated care that was responsive to their individual goals and preferences. The service also worked effectively with a range of specialist services, including dietetics, speech and language therapy, dementia support, wellbeing services and social work, helping to ensure safe and consistent care throughout people's journeys.

Safeguarding

Score: 3

The hospice had a strong culture of safeguarding and placed the safety and wellbeing of people at the centre of care delivery. Staff received safeguarding training appropriate to their role and demonstrated a comprehensive understanding of how to recognise, respond to and report concerns. They were able to describe safeguarding processes confidently and knew how to escalate concerns both internally and externally when required.

There was a clear expectation that safeguarding was everyone's responsibility, and staff spoke positively about the support available from leaders when concerns were identified. Staff understood how to recognise signs of abuse, neglect, exploitation and self-neglect in both adults and children. They also demonstrated awareness of less obvious indicators that could place people at risk.

The hospice had a comprehensive safeguarding system, with clear roles and responsibilities, through which safeguarding risks were proactively identified, managed and actioned. Safeguarding policies for both adults and children were available to all staff. These policies covered all forms of abuse, including domestic abuse, female genital mutilation and radicalisation. The policies were reviewed annually to ensure they remained up to date with current legislation and guidance.

Staff were trained in safeguarding, understood how to make a safeguarding referral and did so when appropriate. All staff had completed safeguarding adults and safeguarding children training to level 3. The safeguarding leads were registered social workers working in senior roles and had completed appropriate safeguarding training to level 4 for both adults and children.

The hospice worked proactively with partner agencies to ensure people received appropriate protection and support when safeguarding concerns arose. Staff demonstrated a clear understanding of multi-agency working and were able to describe how they liaised with local authorities, healthcare professionals and other external organisations to safeguard people effectively. Safeguarding concerns were reviewed through governance processes, and leaders ensured learning was shared across teams to strengthen practice and improve outcomes. Staff viewed safeguarding as an integral part of providing high-quality, person-centred care rather than as a standalone process.

Staff had a clear understanding of the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) and understood these should only be used when they were in a person's best interests. Staff received training in the Mental Capacity Act (MCA), were confident in its application and sought innovative ways to ensure people's human and legal rights were respected.

Staff understood the importance of equality, diversity and human rights in safeguarding practice. They provided examples of how they protected people from harassment, discrimination and abuse, including those with protected characteristics. Staff described how they adapted care to meet individual needs and acted when barriers were identified that could affect people's safety, wellbeing or access to services. Patients and their relatives told us they felt safe using the service and were confident staff would act if concerns were raised.

The service recognised the importance of supporting families and children who visited the hospice and had arrangements in place to ensure visits were safe and appropriate. Staff understood their responsibilities in relation to children's wellbeing and followed procedures designed to protect children and young people visiting the hospice. This included assessing individual circumstances, providing appropriate support and ensuring any concerns were escalated appropriately.

Involving people to manage risks

Score: 4

Staff communicated with patients in ways that supported their understanding of care and treatment, including adapting communication methods for those with communication difficulties.

The service demonstrated a positive approach to risk management, enabling people to maintain as much control over their lives as possible while promoting their safety and wellbeing. Patients were actively involved in decisions about risks associated with their care and support. Staff took time to understand what was important to each person and supported them to make informed choices by balancing individual preferences with safety considerations. Risk assessments were personalised and reflected patients' wishes, goals, and desired outcomes.

Staff demonstrated a proactive approach to identifying, managing, and escalating risks. Concerns identified during care were acted upon promptly and referred to appropriate healthcare professionals when required. This helped ensure risks such as constipation, declining oral health, and skin damage were recognised early and managed effectively. The use of structured assessment tools supported consistent monitoring and enabled patients and their families to better understand and participate in managing risks associated with their condition. As a result, people received responsive care that adapted to their changing needs and reduced the likelihood of avoidable harm.

Staff consistently showed empathy and adopted an enabling approach that encouraged patients to maximise their independence while respecting their lifestyle choices and personal preferences. For example, one patient who was bedbound wished to continue using the toilet with staff support. The service completed a detailed risk assessment and implemented measures to mitigate identified risks wherever possible. Staff discussed the potential risks with the patient, enabling them to make an informed decision. The service recognised that supporting the patient to use the toilet promoted their dignity, independence, and choice and was aligned with their expressed wishes.

Staff demonstrated a detailed understanding of individual risks and adapted activities and environments to enable people to participate safely in activities that were important to them. The service balanced risk and independence effectively, ensuring people benefited from activities that promoted wellbeing without compromising safety. For example, patients receiving oxygen therapy were supported to access outdoor spaces safely where appropriate.

Safe environments

Score: 4

The hospice had created an environment that was safe and enhanced people's wellbeing and quality of life. Leaders recognised that safe environments extended beyond clinical areas and ensured facilities, equipment and therapeutic spaces supported both safety and meaningful engagement.

The inpatient unit was arranged into five pods, each containing four single-occupancy rooms with en-suite facilities. This promoted privacy, dignity and comfort. Each pod included a bright communal area where patients could socialise, as well as quiet rooms for reflection and confidential conversations.

A multi-faith room was available for prayer, worship and reflection, with resources to support a range of beliefs and cultural needs. Larger group rooms were used for family gatherings, celebrations and social activities.

Each inpatient room had direct access to a private patio and garden area. These spaces could accommodate beds when required, enabling people with reduced mobility or complex needs to benefit from fresh air and outdoor environments. Patients spoke positively about the surroundings and wildlife, which contributed to a calm atmosphere.

The hospice also had a large, accessible garden with seating areas, sensory planting and quiet spaces for relaxation. Wide, level pathways enabled access for wheelchair users and hospital beds. The garden was secure and well used by patients, visitors and staff.

Children visiting relatives had access to age-appropriate facilities, including a dedicated play area for younger children and a separate space for older children with films, games and activities. The environment had also been adapted to meet the needs of people living with dementia through measures such as clear signage and digital clocks.

A dedicated bereavement suite provided a peaceful and dignified space for relatives to spend time with their loved one after death. The suite included comfortable facilities and an adjoining temperature-controlled room. A separate garden and discreet exit enabled relatives, if they wished, to accompany their loved one when they were collected by funeral directors. The hospice also maintained a dedicated cold-storage facility which was appropriately maintained and operated in accordance with best practice.

Hospice at Home staff completed comprehensive assessments of home environments, considering factors such as access, available space, pets, household occupants and other potential risks.

The hospice demonstrated a proactive approach to environmental safety. Leaders maintained oversight of key risks, including fire safety, water safety, electrical systems and medical oxygen provision. Environmental risk assessments were reviewed regularly, and external specialists provided independent assurance.

Fire risk assessments were reviewed annually, actions from audits had been completed and staff participated in practical evacuation exercises, which they said improved their confidence in responding to emergencies.

An on-site facilities team ensured equipment and infrastructure were maintained to a high standard. Medical equipment was serviced and inspected regularly. The hospice also demonstrated strong business continuity arrangements, including a regularly tested standby generator and partnership working with local emergency response organisations. Staff provided examples of environmental incidents, including flooding, being managed effectively.

Systems were in place to manage water safety risks, including legionella monitoring and specialist external support. Leaders monitored actions arising from external inspections and audits and used these to drive improvement.

The service responded proactively to emerging risks, including extreme weather. Leaders had registered for national heat alerts and invested in additional cooling equipment to improve comfort for patients and staff during periods of high temperature.

The hospice promoted a safe and sustainable environment through measures to improve energy efficiency, reduce waste and use resources responsibly. This included the reuse and resale of equipment no longer required. The development and maintenance of nature-connected spaces further enhanced the environment for patients, relatives, visitors and staff.

Safe and effective staffing

Score: 4

The service had enough suitably qualified, skilled and experienced staff to keep people safe and provide effective care and treatment.

There were well-established systems to ensure people received timely access to medical support. The service was led by a palliative care consultant. There were always consultants and or resident doctors on site. There were responsive on-call arrangements outside normal working hours when consultants were not on site. Staff told us consultants attend promptly in an emergency, ensuring people's healthcare needs were met without delay. The palliative care consultants and other doctors were substantively employed by the local NHS trust.

The service employed 2 Advanced Clinical Practitioners (ACPs) who worked autonomously within their scope of practice, managing complex clinical care, diagnosing conditions and prescribing treatments.

Care was delivered by a multidisciplinary workforce comprising registered nurses, palliative care support workers, doctors, homemakers and volunteers. Homemakers provided practical and social support to patients, including assisting with meals, providing refreshments and spending time with patients. Volunteers received training appropriate to their role.

Nursing staff had access to trained mentors who provided additional support when required. Staff told us they felt well supported by colleagues, managers and the wider multidisciplinary team.

All new staff completed an induction programme and worked in a supernumerary capacity until they had developed the necessary skills and confidence to undertake their role independently.

Managers assessed staffing requirements and calculated the number and skill mix of nursing and support staff required. Staffing levels matched planned numbers on all shifts during the inspection period.

Staff had completed mandatory training relevant to their roles and were up to date with training requirements. The service was undertaking a training needs analysis to ensure staff development aligned with the updated Gold Standards Framework (GSF) accreditation standards for end-of-life care.

Staff received regular supervision and support through meetings with their line managers. Psychological support was available to staff following challenging events, such as the death of a patient with complex needs. Staff also described a positive and supportive culture, where colleagues provided peer support and shared learning.

The service operated safer recruitment processes. Staff and volunteers were required to provide two satisfactory references and complete Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks before commencing employment. The provider renewed DBS checks every three years in line with its policy and monitored professional registrations to ensure staff remained appropriately registered.

Workforce indicators demonstrated a stable staffing establishment. Staff turnover had reduced from 4.35% in 2024/25 to 3.39% in 2025/26. Workforce stability was high, with 97.5% of staff having more than 12 months' service, exceeding the provider's target range. Sickness absence rates were low, with short-term absence at 1.19% and long-term absence at 0.36%.

The provider actively supported staff development and career progression. Examples included funding for a nurse undertaking a Master's degree in Dementia Studies and supporting palliative care support workers to complete nursing degree programmes. All staff were supported to complete training in palliative care, end of life care and advanced communication skills.

Infection prevention and control

Score: 3

Patients were protected from the risk of infection as far as possible because the hospice environment and equipment were maintained in a clean and hygienic condition. The hospice was visibly clean, and furnishings were suitable, easy to clean, and well maintained.

Staff maintained equipment effectively and ensured it was clean. All ‘clean’ stickers were clearly visible and within their expiry dates.

Storage areas were tidy, with stock stored in an organised manner to enable efficient cleaning and checking. Clear arrangements were in place to assess and manage infection risks. A senior manager acted as the hospice's Infection Prevention and Control Lead, providing oversight of infection prevention and control activities.

Cleaning records were up to date and demonstrated that ward areas were cleaned regularly.

Staff consistently adhered to infection prevention and control principles, including effective hand hygiene practices, both within the hospice and when delivering care in patients' homes. Adequate supplies of personal protective equipment (PPE), including gloves and aprons, were available to support the safe delivery of care and procedures. Handwashing sinks and alcohol hand sanitiser dispensers were readily accessible throughout the hospice, and information promoting effective handwashing was displayed at sink locations. During the inspection, staff were observed washing their hands and using hand sanitiser between patient contacts. Staff were bare below the elbow in line with policy.

Medicines optimisation

Score: 3

Medicines optimisation processes supported the safe and effective delivery of care, with clear governance arrangements, good multidisciplinary working and a culture of learning from incidents to improve patient safety.

Staff managed medicines safely and in line with national guidance and best practice. There were appropriate policies, systems and processes to support the safe prescribing, storage, administration, recording, reconciliation and disposal of medicines. This included arrangements for antimicrobial prescribing and a self-medication policy for patients who were able and wished to manage their own medicines.

There were appropriate and effective arrangements for the management of controlled drugs. Controlled drugs were stored securely and managed in accordance with relevant legislation. The service had a Controlled Drugs Accountable Officer responsible for providing oversight and assurance regarding the safe management of controlled medicines. Controlled drug audits were undertaken regularly, with audit results from January to March 2026 demonstrating 96% compliance. Where areas for improvement were identified, actions were taken to address them.

Hospice at home staff worked collaboratively with GPs, pharmacies and community healthcare teams to ensure patients received timely access to medicines and effective symptom management. Patients experienced coordinated care, particularly in relation to pain management and the control of symptoms such as nausea, breathlessness and fatigue. Patients and families were provided with information and support to help them understand medicines being used, including the purpose and management of syringe drivers.

Staff had access to accurate and up-to-date medicines information. When patients moved between health and care settings, medicines information was shared appropriately to support continuity of care and reduce the risk of errors. During the inspection, we observed staff following medicines administration procedures, including checking patients’ identities before administering medicines.

The service had systems for reporting, investigating and learning from medicines-related incidents. Staff completed incident reports when medicines were omitted or not administered as prescribed. Medicines incidents and errors were reviewed through weekly incident meetings to identify trends, share learning and reduce the risk of recurrence.

Oxygen was managed safely. Staff monitored oxygen usage daily and maintained oversight of stock levels to ensure adequate supplies were available. Leaders demonstrated effective management of infrastructure risks, including taking action to increase oxygen capacity following identified concerns regarding storage and supply arrangements. Contingency plans were in place to minimise disruption to patients during essential engineering works, including arrangements for alternative oxygen provision. Leaders responded promptly to emerging risks and worked collaboratively with partner agencies to support the continuity and safety of patient care.