• Care Home
  • Care home

Aston House

Overall: Inadequate read more about inspection ratings

45 Hampton Park Road, Hereford, Herefordshire, HR1 1TJ (01432) 267996

Provided and run by:
Aston House Care Ltd

Important: The provider of this service changed - see old profile

Assessment report published 17 November 2026

On this page

Safe

Inadequate

17 November 2026

Safe – this means we looked for evidence that people were protected from abuse and avoidable harm. At our last assessment we rated this key question requires improvement. At this assessment the rating has changed to inadequate.

This meant people were not safe and were at risk of avoidable harm.

The service was in breach of legal regulation in relation to safe care and treatment.

This service scored 38 (out of 100) for this area. Find out what we look at when we assess this area and How we calculate these scores.

Learning culture

Score: 1

The provider did not demonstrate a positive learning culture. They failed to take sufficient action to address concerns identified at the previous inspection and did not comply with all additional conditions imposed on the registration of Aston House. As a result, significant shortfalls remained indicating lessons had not been effectively learned or embedded into practice.

Care records and risk assessments were not always reviewed or updated following significant incidents. For example, following an incident involving a person, records stated that risk assessments and care plans had been reviewed; however, there was no evidence these documents had been amended to reflect the incident or any learning identified.

There were no effective systems in place to review and learn from medicines errors, including incidents involving incorrect dosages and missed medicines. Medication error report forms showed management reviews of medicines incidents were frequently incomplete and, where reviews had taken place, there was no evidence of meaningful analysis or actions to reduce the risk of recurrence. There was no evidence that the provider had undertaken a root cause analysis, considered whether staff competency had contributed to the error, reviewed whether additional training or supervision was required, or assessed whether care plans and risk assessments needed to be updated. Lack of analysis meant that there was no learning from this type of event which could be shared and used to prevent re-occurrence.
 

Safe systems, pathways and transitions

Score: 1

The provider did not work well with people and health system partners to establish and maintain safe systems of care. They did not manage or monitor people’s safety.

The provider did not have a robust and safe system in place to ensure that people’s care records contained sufficient guidance for staff to follow. One person had dietary restrictions associated with a health condition. Although their care plan referred to specific guidance relating to the management of their health condition, when inspectors requested a copy of this guidance the provider was unable to provide it and the manager was unaware of where it was held.


Another person's care plan contained guidance to contact relevant healthcare professionals in specific circumstances to support the safe management of their medicines. Records showed the identified circumstances occurred regularly; however, there was no evidence staff had sought advice or contacted healthcare professionals as directed within the care plan. This meant the person's changing needs were not being appropriately reviewed, placing them at ongoing risk of avoidable harm associated with the administration of their medicines.


The provider did not ensure lessons were learned from fire safety incidents and drills. Information obtained through incidents, fire drills and routine monitoring was not consistently used to assess and mitigate risks or improve emergency evacuation arrangements. Following an incident where a person failed to evacuate during a fire alarm, there was no evidence their PEEP had been reviewed. Likewise, another fire drill identified 3 people had not heard the alarm and failed to evacuate, the provider had not investigated the reasons for this, reviewed people's evacuation plans, or implemented measures to reduce the likelihood of recurrence. Records also showed gaps in fire safety monitoring and maintenance checks. Consequently, the provider could not be assured that people could be evacuated safely in the event of a fire, exposing them to an increased risk of harm.

Safeguarding

Score: 2

The provider did not always work well with people and healthcare partners to understand what being safe meant to them and how to achieve that. They did not always concentrate on improving people’s lives or protecting their right to live in safety, free from avoidable harm and neglect.

Staff practice meant there were some instances where people’s well-being needs were not recognised, and people were at increased risk of neglect. People were also at increased risk of neglect because their health needs were not consistently monitored. However, there were other instances where staff recognised and took appropriate action when they observed poor staff practices or abuse.

We reviewed how the service applied the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA), including the management of Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS). People can only be deprived of their liberty to receive care and treatment with appropriate legal authority. In care homes, this can be done through a procedure called the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS), which is part of the Mental Capacity Act 2005(MCA). We checked whether the service was working within the principles of the MCA and how they managed DoLS within the service. Oversight of people’s DoLS was not robust. One person’s applications had not been notified to CQC.

There was a specific condition attached to 1 person's DoLS authorisation. On the first day of our inspection, there was no evidence the registered provider had complied with the condition. This meant the provider could not demonstrate decisions relating to restrictions on the person's liberty were being made in accordance with the Mental Capacity Act 2005 and the requirements of the DoLS authorisation. Although some action was taken during the inspection process, this did not provide assurance that the condition had been complied with in a timely manner or that the person's rights had been consistently protected.

Involving people to manage risks

Score: 1

The provider did not work well with people to understand and manage risks. Staff did not provide care to meet people’s needs that was safe, supportive and enabled people to do the things that mattered to them.

While some people had been involved in developing risk management arrangements, the provider did not ensure these remained effective. For example, agreements relating to the amount of alcohol people could bring into the service were repeatedly exceeded. There was no evidence that these arrangements had been discussed with the people involved, reviewed to see whether they were working, or changed when it became clear they were not effective. As a result, the provider could not demonstrate that people were being supported to actively manage risks in a way that promoted their safety and wellbeing.


One person had a diagnosed mental health condition and regularly consumed excessive quantities of energy drinks. Despite this being a known and ongoing concern, there was no evidence the registered provider had sought comprehensive advice from relevant healthcare professionals regarding the potential impact of excessive caffeine consumption on the person's mental health, physical health, or prescribed medicines. The provider had not adequately assessed the risks associated with high caffeine intake, including the potential to exacerbate mental health symptoms, adversely affect physical health, increase heart rate and blood pressure, or reduce the effectiveness of prescribed treatment. There was also no evidence of a coordinated plan developed with the person and relevant professionals to manage or reduce these risks. As a result, the provider could not demonstrate that risks relating to the person's health, wellbeing and treatment were appropriately assessed, monitored and mitigated, or that the person was being supported to make informed decisions about managing these risks.


 

Safe environments

Score: 2

The provider did not always detect and control potential risks in the care environment. They did not always make sure equipment, facilities and technology supported the delivery of safe care.

The provider did not ensure environmental risks were effectively assessed, monitored and mitigated to protect people from harm. Records relating to the inspection and maintenance of fire-fighting equipment contained significant gaps, including an absence of evidence of checks between November 2025 and June 2026 and no evidence that checks had been completed during July 2026. Consequently, the registered provider could not demonstrate that fire-fighting equipment had been routinely inspected, maintained and remained available for use in an emergency.

In addition, the provider was unable to provide evidence that water systems had been tested for legionella in accordance with their own risk assessment and monitoring arrangements. This meant the provider could not demonstrate that appropriate measures were in place to identify and control the risk of exposure to waterborne bacteria.

These omissions demonstrated a failure to maintain effective oversight of key environmental safety risks and meant the provider could not assure themselves, or others, that appropriate systems were in place to protect people from foreseeable harm.
 

Safe and effective staffing

Score: 2

The provider did not always make sure there were enough qualified, skilled and experienced staff.They did not always work together well to provide safe care that met people’s individual needs.

Staff did not always demonstrate the knowledge and competence required to support people safely. For example, one person had been assessed as lacking capacity to make decisions relating to their health and wellbeing and required a specific diet to manage their diabetes. When we asked staff how they supported the person to manage their dietary needs, staff told us they would show the person a bar of chocolate and allow them to decide how much they wanted. Staff told us it was the person's right to make an unwise decision, despite the person having been assessed as lacking capacity in relation to decisions about their health and wellbeing.

This demonstrated a significant gap in staff understanding of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. Staff incorrectly applied the principle of unwise decisions to a person who had been assessed as lacking capacity to make decisions about their health and wellbeing. This placed the person at risk of receiving inappropriate support and exposed them to avoidable risks associated with the management of their diabetes.

People and staff confirmed there were enough staff to support people.

The provider followed recruitment procedures to ensure all required checks were completed before staff started work at the service. Enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks were carried out. DBS checks provide information about convictions and cautions held on the police national computer. The information helps employers make safer recruitment decisions.
 

Infection prevention and control

Score: 2

The provider did not always assess or manage the risk of infection. They did not always detect and control the risk of it spreading or share concerns with appropriate agencies promptly.

The registered provider failed to ensure that food was stored safely and that risks relating to infection prevention and control were appropriately managed. During the first day of our inspection, we identified multiple concerns regarding food storage practices. We found food items that had exceeded their use-by dates and opened food that remained in use beyond recommended timescales. We also found unlabelled food items, where the date of opening was unknown, and foods requiring refrigeration that were not stored appropriately. As a result, the provider could not demonstrate that food was consistently stored in a manner that ensured it remained safe for consumption. These failings increased the risk of food contamination and foodborne illness, placing people at risk of avoidable harm.


In addition to concerns regarding food storage, we found poor standards of environmental cleanliness throughout the service. This included visibly soiled bathroom facilities, mould growth on a bathmat accessible to people using a communal bathroom, and mould present within a drinks bottle located in a communal area. These concerns created a risk of cross-contamination and infection transmission and did not provide assurance that the environment was being maintained in a hygienic condition.
 

Medicines optimisation

Score: 1

The provider did not make sure that medicines and treatments were safe and met people’s needs, capacities and preferences.

The registered provider did not ensure medicines were managed safely. Arrangements for monitoring the storage temperatures of medicines requiring refrigeration were ineffective. Consequently, the provider could not provide assurance that the quality, integrity and effectiveness of refrigerated medicines had been maintained, or that out-of-range temperatures would be identified, escalated and addressed appropriately.

Systems for reviewing medicines incidents and learning from errors were also ineffective. Records we reviewed were incomplete. Errors in the administration of medicines had not been identified, and we saw no evidence that action had taken place to reduce the risk of errors reoccurring. For example, incidents involving a missing tablet and a missed dose of antibiotics were recorded as isolated events and closed without further investigation. The registered provider had not undertaken root cause analysis, considered whether staff competency had contributed to the incidents, identified any training or supervision needs, or reviewed whether care plans and risk assessments required updating. As a result, they could not demonstrate that lessons were learned from medicines errors to improve people's safety.

Care plans and risk assessments did not consistently consider the impact of alcohol, illicit substances and excessive caffeine consumption on people's physical and mental health or the potential interactions with prescribed medicines.

People were not always protected from the risks associated with 'when required' (PRN) medicines. Not all people prescribed PRN medicines had corresponding PRN protocols in place. Despite this, staff had administered PRN medicines in circumstances where person-centred guidance was absent, contrary to the provider's own policies and procedures. There was no clear guidance for staff on when PRN medicines should be administered or what alternative approaches should be considered first. As a result, the provider could not demonstrate that these medicines were being given safely, consistently, or in line with people's assessed needs.

These concerns demonstrated ineffective medicines governance and a failure to ensure medicines-related risks were appropriately assessed, monitored and mitigated, placing people at risk of avoidable harm.